Toxic Empathy

How Progressives Exploit Christian Compassion

By: Allie Beth Stuckey

Narrated by: Allie Beth Stuckey

A sharp Christian voice makes a bold argument: when politics are driven by empathy rather than truth, innocent people pay the price.

We are told that empathy is the highest virtue—the key to being a good person. Is that true? Or has “empathy,” like so many other words of our day—“tolerance,” “justice,” “acceptance”—been hijacked by bad actors who exploit compassion for their own political ends?

In Toxic Empathy, Allie Beth Stuckey argues that empathy has become a tool of manipulation by left-wing activists who bully people into believing that they must adopt progressive positions to be loving. She explores the five most heated issues through which toxic empathy is deployed: abortion, gender, sexuality, immigration, and social justice. Progressives use catchy mantras to present their perspective as empathetic, like “abortion is healthcare,” “love is love,” or “no human being is illegal,” but in each case, they ignore the other side of the moral equation. For example, abortion is presented as compassionate for the woman, but what about the human life the procedure kills?

This book isn’t about killing empathy; it’s about submitting our empathy to God’s definitions of love, goodness, and justice. Stuckey exposes the logical pitfalls and moral consequences of toxic empathy, equipping Christians with research-backed, Biblical truths to dismantle the progressive lies that have permeated our culture—and our church.

©2024 Allie Beth Stuckey (P)2024 Penguin Audio

Critic reviews

“Most lies are wrapped in partial truths, often conveyed through heartbreaking stories. In Toxic Empathy, Allie Beth shares poignant thoughts from diverse viewpoints, offering insight as to why people (and even Christians) come to such different conclusions. Using scripture, reason, and reality, Stuckey advocates for the conservative position while still acknowledging where progressives are coming from.”—Hillary Morgan Ferrer, bestselling author of Mama Bear Apologetics

"Toxic Empathy exposes how unsuspecting Christians play into Satan’s plot to pit compassion against the truth—as though we can be more merciful than God. Allie Beth exposes that Satan’s ploy is to hamstring Christians to believe that empathy—standing in the shoes of someone else—is the highest expression of love. She addresses five lies of our age, illustrating Christian wisdom and compassion as she exposes what Satan wants to conceal. Every page is a lifeline of sanity, common sense, Christian wisdom, and gospel evangelism. A brilliant book every Christian should read.”—Rosaria Butterfield, bestselling author of The Secret Thoughts of an Unlikely Convert

“As a woman passionately committed to defending the most vulnerable, I can’t recommend this book highly enough. Give it to the high schoolers in your life. It will both alert them to the manipulative tactics routinely brandished against good-hearted people as well as make them experts who can stand firm on behalf of the least of these.”—Katy Faust, founder of Them Before Us

I already liked her

I love the way she laid out her arguments. So clear and concise, illustrating that empathy alone is not a virtue, but requires truth as well.

Must read!!!

Everyone needs to read this especially before the election. Allie states facts and biblical truths everyone especially voting christians need to know.

Perfect Timing

Another excellent book by Allie. Timing couldn’t be more perfect. In a world where we are told to empathize with every single feeling, the world has taken it too far. Allie does an excellent job breaking down how that is toxic and how we are called for more.

Solid

Grateful for Allie Beth Stuckey's bold stance and the references to her solid foundation. Although I am more accustomed to hearing her speak more conversationally, her narration was still pleasant and enjoyable (although it was clear she was reading her work).

Clear and to the point… biblically backed 👏🏼

Loved this book. Helped me clear up ways to vocalize in a quick way responses/arguments to several cultural issues. Will be purchasing a copy for my liberal mother in law.

Fantastic

Thank you ABS for writing this. A succinct explanation of why progressive arguments fail to be harmonious with Christianity.

Much needed clarity for a confused society

Such a clear and insightful perspective! We are called to have empathy, but we are also called to speak truth. We are called to love, but we are also called to live under the governing laws of our nation. Empathy speaks truth with compassion. Toxic empathy simply agrees with whatever opinion seems to be right at the moment, and leads to destruction.

Excellent Work!

Absolutely LOVED this book! Allie Beth has done an outstanding job! Every believer and unbeliever for that matter should read this important book.

Exactly what Christians need to hear

It can be intimidating to speak up in this political and cultural climate for what is good, true and right according to the Word of God. In this book, Allie helps you to discern the lies of the world by exposing them to the light of God’s Word. I can’t imagine one walking away from the contents of this book without feeling convicted and compelled to stand in the gap for the defenseless and needy, even if it means enduring arrows from the enemy.

Solid biblical truth!

Loved how Allie Beth carefully debunks the 5 lies and supports them with biblical truth. Love all of the real life stories she shares at the beginning of each chapter. Best book I’ve read/listened to in a while and very educational too!