This Fierce People

The Untold Story of America's Revolutionary War in the South

By: Alan Pell Crawford

Narrated by: Cary Hite

Length: 12 hrs and 16 mins

Publisher's summary

A groundbreaking, important recovery of history; the overlooked story—fully explored—of the critical aspect of America’s Revolutionary War that was fought in the South, showing that the British surrender at Yorktown was the direct result of the southern campaign, and that the battles that emerged south of the Mason-Dixon line between loyalists to the Crown and patriots who fought for independence were, in fact, America’s first civil war.

The famous battles that form the backbone of the story put forth of American independence—at Lexington and Concord, Brandywine, Germantown, Saratoga, and Monmouth—while crucial, did not lead to the surrender at Yorktown.

It was in the three-plus years between Monmouth and Yorktown that the war was won.

Alan Pell Crawford’s riveting new book, This Fierce People, tells the story of these missing three years, long ignored by historians, and of the fierce battles fought in the South that made up the central theater of military operations in the latter years of the Revolutionary War, upending the essential American myth that the War of Independence was fought primarily in the North.

Weaving throughout the stories of the heroic men and women, largely unsung patriots—African Americans and whites, militiamen and “irregulars,” patriots and Tories, Americans, Frenchmen, Brits, and Hessians, Crawford reveals the misperceptions and contradictions of our accepted understanding of how our nation came to be, as well as the national narrative that America’s victory over the British lay solely with General George Washington and his troops.

©2024 Alan Pell Crawford (P)2024 Random House Audio

Evan's Review

When you ask most Americans when the Revolutionary War ended they would say after the Battle of Yorktown. Most people don't realize that alot of Battles took place after Yorktown in South Carolina that basically turn into a Civil War between the Loyalist Mitias and Patriots. I strongly recommend this book to get a better understand of the War until 1783.

It's a good book, but...

I enjoyed the content of the book. If you are unfamiliar with the geography of North and South Carolina it would help to familiarize yourself with a map, preferably from the period, of the towns and rivers in both states to be able to get the most out of listening. The narrator is not good at all. He regularly mispronounces words, and not just names of people and places (whose pronunciations can be difficult), but also "regular" standard words, and some of those he mispronounces differently at different times. His narration also makes it virtually impossible to discern when speech is a direct quote and when it is being paraphrased by the author. Read, rather than listen to this one.

Good history for audiobook format

Good history of the Revolutionary War campaigns in the South, with rich enough context to understand the story, but not too much to bog down the narrative.

The author did an excellent job on staying focus on the topic, the temptation to expound on the whole of the Revolutionary War must have been hard to resist. I learned a lot. Battles are clearly described, the narration is engaging.

I particularly appreciated that chapters tended to be 'self-contained", that is, for the most part, characters and their relevant contribution to the story where all in the same chapter, which makes it easy to follow when listening (as opposed to books where context and characters are presented first, and the narrative follows later, no biggie in printed format when you can go back easily, not so in audio format).

Ghastly

After 500+ audible listens this was the worse.
The narrator: he stops and starts sentences, pauses and inflects precisely when he shouldn't. Next, any word beyond about two syllables will be mispronounced. Names? Anything more complex than "Washington " will probably be mangled. Dude, find a new gig.
Author: This is NOT a book about the southern campaign. The best description is its sort of a rambling social history of the period. I think the author really wanted to write a book about the horrors of slavery, successful colonial business women and the siege of Quebec. The portion of the book actually focused on the southern campaign was superficial and not much beyond Wikipedia text. You've been warned. Skip this groaner.