The Element of Fire

Ile-Rien Series, Book 1

By: Martha Wells

Narrated by: Derek Perkins

The kingdom of Ile-Rien lies in peril, menaced by sorcerous threats and devious court intrigues. As the weak King Roland, flattered and misled by treacherous companions, rules the country, only his ruthless mother, the Dowager Queen Ravenna, guards the safety of the realm. But now rumors arise that Urbain Grandier, the dark master of scientific sorcery, has arrived to plot against the throne. And Kade, bastard sister of King Roland, appears unexpectedly at court. The illegitimate daughter of the old king and the Queen of Air and Darkness herself, Kade's true desires are cloaked in mystery. Is she in league with the wizard Grandier, or is she laying claim to the throne? It falls to Thomas Boniface, Captain of the Queen's Guard and Ravenna's former lover, to sort out who is friend and who is foe in a deadly game to keep the Dowager Queen and the kingdom she loves from harm. But is one man's steel enough to counter all the magic of fayre?

©1993 Martha Wells (P)2013 Tantor

Critic reviews

"Skillfully blending the fantastical and the mundane, Wells delights with deft and sympathetic characterization while demonstrating a fine touch for adventure." ( Publishers Weekly)

the ending was a bit of a letdown but the ride was worth it.

ending didn't quite get me but overall the book was good and the performance very well narrated.

Very entertaining

The tale involves an interesting cast of characters with multiple villains, protagonists who keep trying despite terrible risks, and important characters with significant weaknesses. The plot gallops along with many twists and turns.
The narration is very good. There are a few instances of dialogue that I found hard to follow because I couldn’t discern any difference between the voices of the characters.

Pacing struggles but very fun

I struggled a bit to get into the story at first, but ended up having a great time after Kade came in. After that it was a really fun ride:D

Great storytelling

Enjoyed it from the start. Can’t wait to open the second book to see what the main characters do next.

Action packed, but lacking something

Superbly narrated by Derek Perkins. He's a pro. As for the story, it's action-packed, coherent, and mildly complex. Good dialogue. Gruesome. Some sections are vividly gripping, some parts went on too long, and some scenes are just plain sad. I think King Roland -- so lacking in self-esteem -- made the greatest impression on me. His portrayal felt realistic.

However, the weak king is a secondary character. I didn't get into the main characters. I wish Wells would devote a greater percentage of the text to characterization and relationship development. She is strong on plot and action -- which is important -- but I need to care about the characters, and that means I need to know them, individually and as a team.

So, after half a dozen false starts, I finally got into the characters just enough to stay the course. This is primarily a kingdom based fantasy, with a romantic relationship on the side. I didn't get deeply drawn into the story of Kade and Thomas, because his past affair with Queen Ravenna overshadowed it.

The fantastical elements include shape shifting, wizards, wards, dark fey from the Unseelie Court, light fey from the Seelie Court (Tatiana and Oberon).

Lots of unnatural disgusting creatures. Lots of bloody battles. Treason, court intrigues, and various betrayals. A few kisses. Cool scenes of the castle, home of the Queen of Darkness and Air (aka Kade).

I liked this book, but not as much as her award-winning The Death of the Necromancer.

MUST LISTEN

I felt that narrator is amazing and the story is so captivating I couldn’t stop listening!

Well realized fantasy world

This the first Martha Wells outside of her magnificent MurderBot Diaries series I have read. Like other reviewers I was slow to get into the story, but about 5 chapters in it grabbed me. She has a real talent for moving action along while at the same time painting a detailed rendition of her fantasy world. Ile Rien is a D&D world so I recommend it to those types particularly. She also is good at strong, capable women - not Wonder Woman or Xeena types, just capable, strong-minded females who are central to the story. Derek Peters does a great read, although using a female reader as well might have made some of it easier to follow.

Started a little confusing, but found its footing

The particular moment left me feeling disoriented for a while. Things didn’t start becoming clearer until around page 50 or so. For me, that’s when the book really started to answer my question, “To what end?” While I saw a certain reveal coming, I was pleasantly surprised she didn’t let that drag out to the end. She introduced it about midway through the story, which gave the plot room to explore other things. Once things started to happen, this book built momentum, escalating fairly quickly by the time readers start nearing the middle of the book.

However, with the momentum came a few hiccups. There were way too many instances of buildup for certain plot points and then, the denouement for these things didn’t deliver that satisfying sense of closure one expects, which is a little frustrating. Some other things that were twined into the plot had a tendency to come off as “Oh my, what a coincidence!” moments, followed abruptly with, “Well, if that was the case, why didn’t they do/say/tell [insert scenario here] instead of nothing?” Some things seem to started to buildup to something interesting and then suddenly fizzle out.

I liked most of the main characters. Ravenna, Thomas, Grandier, and Kade really got to shine throughout the book. Grandier’s gray morality and “be the monster they made you” attitude was interesting. I loved Ravenna, especially the fact that, unlike other book queens, Ravenna surrounded herself with gentlewomen and queen’s servants that she taught to be as scrupulous and quick-thinking as herself. Her servants were not fodder. She saw no use in having servants around her that couldn’t prove themselves useful for more than just their serving skills. Other characters felt a little weaker in their roles, such as the King and Queen, but they had a few memorable moments.

This book was part fantasy, part mystery. I’m curious about the Seelie and Unseelie Courts and wonder if I’ll see more of them in future books. Derek Perkins was an engaging narrator and an excellent voice for this series. His vocal characterization of both Ravenna and Kade were my favorites. I’ll continue to listen to the audiobooks for his narration. I loved the various little pieces of the puzzle coming together throughout the book, even if I felt the ultimate reveal was very dramatic against the more mellow tone of the story, especially considering how so many points had such underwhelming conclusions. I wasn’t as taken with this book as I was The Cloud Roads. The Cloud Roads feels like the type of book that I would use to introduce people to Wells’ work, but I had fun with this book all the same.

Strangely pretty good

The Element of Fire was pretty good I thought. It was a little hard to follow at times, but for the most part it was a very good read. Thomas and Kade are both fantastic Characters and Wells does a good job creating the world they live in. Add a happy ending in for good luck and you've got yourself a pretty darn good book.

Narration wasn't the worlds greatest, but it wasn't bad either. Worth a credit/money.

Missing something

I love this author's Murderbot series, and would very much like to support her with good reviews, but this is not anywhere near as good. I spent the first couple hours wondering what I was doing here-- and wondering if maybe I had missed a prequel. Characters and names kept popping up all over the place with no real indication of who they were and how they were going to fit into the story. I finally got something of a handle on key characters, and some sense of what might be the real story-- and then got lost in the locations popping up everywhere. The author seemed to have a clear picture of what was where, and seemed to think that I should too, but I absolutely did not. I gave up and suspended my attention to such things, and just let the action carry me-- but the action went on and on and on without clear progress on the plot points. And then it ended. It did wrap things up, but the rhythm was all off, by the time there was a climax I was so mired in the endless action that I almost missed it. So-- when is the next Murderbot coming out?