Lost Books and Old Bones

Scottish Bookshop Mystery Series, Book 3

By: Paige Shelton

Narrated by: Susan Boyce

Delaney Nichols, originally of Kansas but settling happily into her new life as a bookseller in Edinburgh, works at The Cracked Spine in the heart of town. She's recently befriended a few medical school students after they came into the shop to sell some antique medical tomes. But when one of the students' friends is found murdered outside in the alley, Delaney takes it upon herself to help bring the murderer to justice.

During her investigation, Delaney finds some old scalpels in the bookshop's warehouse - she finds out that they belonged to a long-dead doctor whose story might be connected to the present-day murder. It's all Delaney can do to race to solve this crime before time runs out and she ends up in danger herself.

©2018 Paige Shelton-Ferrell (P)2018 Tantor

Great Mystery!!

Lots of twists and turns - and never did pick the killer. Enjoy the relationships between the characters also - but need Edwin to be less elusive and distant!
Have to say i would have preferred ‘Carrington MacDuffie’ to have continued to read the series - missed her narration!

Switch up

This is book #3. I had gotten used to the narrator in books 1 & 2 & was a little let down with the new narrator’s voices in Chapter one...Don’t give up!!! Susan Boyce brings a wonderful interpretation in with her voices & narrative. By chapter three, book 1 & 2 narrator’s voice had faded. Totally an enjoyable book for my daily walk & commute.

Wonderful book

I love the series. I have read the whole series four times. I love the mix of mystery and the romance. I can’ t wait for next book!

Loved the series and this book, but

What happened to Carrington MacDuffie as the narrator? I’ve enjoyed books narrated by Susan Boyce but I thought Ms. MacDuffie really had the voice for this series.

HATE the narrator, Susan Boyce.

Loved the narrator from the first 2 books in this series. She really made it seem like you were in Scotland! Can only listen to Boyce for a small amount of time before I want to reach thru the phone and strangle Boyce. Hate her in other books as well.

Lost me with the poor Scottish accent.

Having listened to the first 2 books and enjoyed them, I am let down by the narration of the the third. It is usually tough to get used to a new voice but eventually I get over it. The original narrator had the Scots down perfectly. My only criticism of her was that she made Delaney sound a bit naive (but maybe this was intentional interpretation since the character is from Kansas ). The new narrator is ok with the non accented narration but her Scottish accent is horrible!! I just got back from Scotland (visiting relatives) and this new narrator actually sounds IRISH not Scottish. She pronounces certain words incorrectly like the word "close" (as in alley). She pronounces it close as in "close the door". It's supposed to be as in "close together". I will still stick with the books but may end up reading instead of listening if they continue to use the same narrator.

Best of the series so far.

I liked the world this book evoked and characters were enjoyable. I was surprised at the ending. Good book.

Best of the series

Good, clean, fun mystery. This book is an easy listen and very entertaining. This read was like comfort food...an enjoyable time.

An exciting Scottish mystery

As <strong>Lost Books and Old Bones</strong> by Paige Shelton opens, Delaney Nichols has gone to a pub one Friday night with two friends who are medical students at Edinburgh University. Sophie and Rena introduce the American from Kansas working at the Cracked Spine, the store specializing in old and rare books, to their fellow medical student, Mallory. She also meets the strange Dr. Eban, who loves to espouse the good things that William Burke and William Hare did for scientific advances in the early 19th century. The two notorious men committed 16 murders in order to create their own supply of cadavers that they sold to Dr. Knox of Edinburgh University to dissect. Though this history might seem arcane, it figures into the plot of this book. As the four women leave the pub, they split up in different cabs.

The next morning, Delany arrives at work to learn that someone broke into the bookstore sometime during the night. Further, somebody has been murdered in the close, the Scottish term for alley, right outside the window of the bookshop, which has had its glass broken. The murdered woman is Mallory. Delany traverses a lot of ground in researching artifacts that seem connected to the case and in chasing down a murderer.

I enjoyed the previous two books in this series, but this is the best so far. We get to travel back in history to the days of Burke and Hare. We see suspicious old scalpels and tour the Skull Room at Edinburgh University, with over 1,000 skulls in it. We also attend a service to honor those people who have donated their bodies to science for medical students to dissect. And we see a more recent case of a murder scandal at Edinburgh University. The book has a great storyline with many fascinating details.

<strong>Lost Books and Old Bones</strong> takes us on a fun tour of Edinburgh, Scotland as Delany does her research into the murder and looks into the past. We learn a bit about Scotland, with plenty of flavor of the land. We get introduced to terminology used by the Scots, as the American Delany gets people to translate such terms for her. I also found the tours of the University of Edinburgh and the museum to be fascinating.

The characters in this book come across as delightful. We really identify with Delany and find her very real, a mixture of intrepid and cautious. The reporter, Bridget, grows on us. When we first meet her, she seems like a nasty woman, but she develops into a more helpful person as the book progresses. The other characters exhibit similar human traits that make us identify with them well.

Susan Boyce performs the audio edition of this book. I think she is an outstanding narrator, with strong, but not too strong, expression. Her voices suit the characters' natures, and I like her Scottish accent. My only problem is that I have gotten to know her voice so well as she narrates the Cupcake Mystery Series by Jenn McKinlay, which I have listened to regularly, so I tended to hear the characters from that series in this performance. However, she still makes the book seem strong in its audiobook edition.

I thoroughly appreciated the experience of listening to <strong>Lost Books and Old Bones</strong>. This book came across cleverly, with a very interesting storyline and side plots, as well as very believable characters. I give the book five stars.

A nice mystery with a side of Scottish history

I kind of picked this series up by a whim and each story has grown in history and mystery, I like that the main character, Delaney Nichols, does depend on others. I enjoyed the Burke and Hare stories and the best compliment I can give is I know want to know more.
There was a narrator change this book. and I enjoyed Susan Boyce doing the voices this time.