Bismarck's War

The Franco-Prussian War and the Making of Modern Europe

De: Rachel Chrastil

Narrado por: Sarah Borges

A new history of the war that toppled the French Empire, unified Germany, and set Europe on the path to World War I

Among the conflicts that convulsed Europe during the nineteenth century, none was more startling and consequential than the Franco-Prussian War of 1870-1871. Deliberately engineered by Prussian chancellor Otto von Bismarck, the war succeeded in shattering French supremacy, deposing Napoleon III, and uniting a new German Empire. But it also produced brutal military innovations and a precarious new imbalance of power that together set the stage for the devastating world wars of the next century.

In Bismarck’s War, historian Rachel Chrastil chronicles events on the battlefield in full, while also showing in intimate detail how the war reshaped and blurred the boundaries between civilian and soldier as the fighting swept across France. The result is the definitive history of a transformative conflict that changed Europe, and the history of warfare, forever.

PLEASE NOTE: When you purchase this title, the accompanying PDF will be available in your Audible Library along with the audio.

©2023 Rachel Chrastil (P)2023 Basic Books

Reseñas de la Crítica

“Rachel Chrastil colorfully describes how the Franco-Prussian War destroyed the long European peace established after Napoleon's defeat in 1815. Beginning as a midsummer cabinet war between monarchs, one of them Napoleon's nephew, Bismarck's invasion of France bogged down in winter rain and snow, and became a rancorous war of peoples that kindled the inferno of World War I.”—Geoffrey Wawro, author of The Franco-Prussian War and A Mad Catastrophe

Kind of hard to follow

The booked jumped around a bit chronologically and kind of made things hard to follow. Also for a book called Bismarck’s war, there is precious little about Bismarck.

Excellent performance, story not so much

Reader was very good. Very little about Bismarck. Book did not represent its title at all.

No breathing space in the narration

It's a good solid book overall, giving anecdotes from individuals involved in the war.
The narrator has good inflection and pronounces French flawlessly. My complaint is that there are no pauses. Natural speech and especially that of actors, leaves space for the reader to absorb what was said and take a break. The narration became tedious rather quickly. I could listen not much more than half an hour at a time.
That said, it's still a good and thorough book that makes its intended point.

Excellent history with overdramatic reader

I appreciate the highly researched and reliably accurate history of this crucial war, not well understood in the US. I wish the beginning had a more complete explanation of the context for the start of the war. The reader tried too hard in my view - I like the choice of a female reader but wished for less drama. A small point- her pronunciation of both French and German words was often grating - languages i know and she often hurt my ears.

Good history of war but limited

Good history of battles and French civilian campaigns but superficial in other areas. Prussia is credited with superior governance (Bismarck and Wilhelm I), better military leadership and training (Moltke, general staff, war college, division level), better military planning (faster German mustering of soldiers, German war plan vs French lack of plan), German deference of civil authority to military on battle field (Wilhelm and Bismarck left command of army to Moltke; Wilhelm ordered Moltke out of Bismarck’s sphere of diplomacy and armistice negotiations, all in line with recent lesson of Lincoln in US Civil War). But why did Prussia excel in all these areas? Little insight from author. Why was French military so poorly prepared for war? Why did French military and generals not adapt to lessons from US Civil War? How did France military and training change after the Franco-Prussian War? This is more a political than military history of the war. The PDF includes a couple maps but lacks diagrams of battles, comparisons of armaments, charts comparing each side’s potential vs actual forces. Performance is very good but sometimes too dramatic. Book could have been much better.

The performance of the reader.

The research was great but the story was incoherent and hard to follow. One at times became lost at what was going in the history.

Incredible

An incredible account of the Franco Prussian War. Sarah Borges made this this wonderfully written book by Rachel Chrastil even better. Dramatically read, perfect tone, and inflection. Perhaps the best I’ve ever heard.

Solid Overview on Looked-Over Topic

While I thought the subject matter was handled well, I felt that it read too much like a blandish university lecture series without an overall thrust to give it some oomph. Still though, if you’re interested in the topic it’s worth a listen. I found the lecturer to be a bit distracting at first but I got used to her.

Not what you think

This is really a book about war crimes in the Franco Prussian war. The author laments page after page of war crime. That’s not why I got this book.

Misleading Title and Poor Narration

I do not think this is a bad book based on its content, but the title is completely misleading regarding how the book approaches the Franco-Prussian War. This book is predominantly from the French perspective, and Bismark's relevance to the book is scarce. Rather than being a political history of the Franco-Prussian War, the author presents the war from the lens of a social historian. In this book, the author uses memoirs from soldiers, civilians, and political leaders from both sides to construct the story.

It is in my opinion, to not read this book as one's first foray into learning about the Franco-Prussian War, but rather as a supplementary piece that builds onto prior knowledge and introduces new subjects into the discussion of the war. The geopolitics and battles however mentioned take a backseat to the social issues presented by the author. Examples include but are not limited to; How did Bavarian soldiers feel about uniting with Prussia? How did German soldiers treat French colonial troops as prisoners? What happened to French women during the occupation? How did French women contribute to the war effort? Furthermore, the events in the book aren't exactly presented in chronological order which makes it hard to follow at times.

However, the narrator selected for this book is just awful. I can't stand listening to her narrating. I credit her pronunciation of French and German. The way she delivers her lines is just bad. She reads the book like she's recording for a bad romance novel. The lack of pauses in her narration makes it hard to follow and the unnecessary stress she puts on French and German words is unnecessary and distracting.

My final opinion is to skip this audiobook. I'd either wait for another person to narrate this book or read it myself.