12, 20, & 5

A Doctor’s Year in Vietnam

De: John A. Parrish

Narrado por: Noah Michael Levine

The candid memoir of a young doctor who reluctantly accepts a military commission and spends a year behind the front lines of the Vietnam War. Assigned to the marine camp at Phu Bai, Dr. John A. Parrish confronted all manner of medical trauma, quickly shedding the navet of a new medical intern.

With this memoir, he crafts a haunting, humane portrait of one man’s agonizing confrontation with war. With a wife and two children awaiting his return home, the young physician lives through the most turbulent and formative year of his life - and finds himself molded into a true doctor by the raw tragedy of the battlefield. His endless work is punctuated only by the arrival of the next helicopter bearing more casualties, and the stark announcements: “12 litter-borne wounded, 20 ambulatory wounded, and 5 dead.”

©1972 John Parrish (P)2014 Audible Inc.

the experience

very personal and emotional. brought the listener into the horrible scene of combat triage and the horror of battle field trama.

Good memoir

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

Yes, it covered a part of history with which I was unfamiliar.

What was one of the most memorable moments of 12, 20, & 5?

The narrator's arrival in country.

How did the narrator detract from the book?

Pronounced Hue as Hugh. Unforgivable.

Was 12, 20, & 5 worth the listening time?

Yes

Stretcher-Ambulatory-Dead

John Parrish, at the time he received his draft notice, was in a residency program at a Michigan hospital. He had three choices. First, John could accept a military commission and spend a year behind the front lines of the Vietnam War, second, he could be a conscientious objector but too much time has already passed or three, he could leave the country that he loved and move to Canada with his wife and two children.

John served one year in Phu Bai, Vietnam. He lived in what was referred to as a hooch, with three other men. One was a surgeon, another was a psychiatrist, the other was a jeep transporter and then there was John, a young doctor who was unsure of his skills as a physician, to care for the injured soldiers fighting in Vietnam.

John learned how to be an excellent trauma doctor with baptism by fire. He learned fast and hard. John's first day in Vietnam was spent taking care of American trauma patient's. The surgeon, Bill, taught him by showing him and having him perform procedures under his tutelage. When John returned home, after having served one year in a Vietnam trauma center, he knew more than he had learned in the six years he had spent at home as an intern and a resident.

I would have given the book four stars but the ending was a bit murky. The memoir of John Parrish was worth the listen. His time spent in Vietnam as a trauma doctor was interesting and was a learning experience for me. The narrator was able to provide the different character's with distinct voices. The character development of John was well done. The other character's who lived with John were good.

Quite a read...

It was a wonderfully touching and personal story. It really brought the horrors of war to a personal level.

Well written, engaging & unique perspective

Parrish renders a good & honest book from a rare perspective, a medical doctor in Vietnam.

Accurate

Was a Marine myself there in 1967-68 in Dong Ha and brought back memories just glad (lucky) I never had the pleasure of meeting Dr Parrish

Surgery

Details of surgery and triage
I was stationed at 3rd Med as surgical technician at same time. Enjoyed the book

Not sure it is not fiction

I endured 8 chapters before I decided this book was not for me. The mispronunciation of Hue started to grind on me. The story line didn't appeal to me. There are many stories about Vietnam, that I have read or listen to better than this one.

Me, me, me

I guess we know who’s the most important. Oh, that would be the wounded? Right?

Might be Bogus

There were so many mispronounced Vietnamese cities that I began to wonder if the reader knew what he was talikng about. (Hue is NOT pronouced "hugh". It is "way" )This was a major military location. It could not be mistaken.

It is a mediocre book at best but you have to wonder if it was all made up.