Episodes

  • The Theological Origins of Modernity by Michael Allen Gillespie
    Nov 24 2024

    In this episode, Jerry and Stably engage in a thoughtful discussion about The Theological Origins of Modernity by Michael Allen Gillespie. The hosts delve into the book’s central thesis that the modern world, often perceived as secular and rational, has deep roots in theological and metaphysical ideas. They explore how Gillespie traces the evolution of modernity back to debates between medieval theologians and their reinterpretation of ancient Greek philosophy.

    The conversation begins with a recap of Gillespie's argument that the Reformation and the Renaissance played pivotal roles in shaping the modern worldview. Stably highlights how the author connects figures like Martin Luther and Descartes to a broader intellectual trajectory, emphasizing their attempts to reconcile human freedom with divine omnipotence. Jerry complements this by discussing how these thinkers laid the groundwork for Enlightenment values, such as individual autonomy and scientific inquiry.

    A key portion of the episode is dedicated to Gillespie’s examination of nominalism—the idea that universals do not exist independently of the mind. Both hosts note how this seemingly abstract philosophical shift had profound implications, undermining the hierarchical, God-centered cosmos of medieval scholasticism and paving the way for a more human-centered perspective. They discuss specific examples from the book, such as the works of William of Ockham and how his ideas challenged traditional notions of order and knowledge.

    Jerry and Stably also tackle the tension between faith and reason, a recurring theme in Gillespie’s analysis. They reflect on how this tension manifested in early modern thinkers, including Galileo and Bacon, who sought to harmonize religious beliefs with empirical science. The hosts provide a nuanced take on the enduring relevance of these debates, drawing parallels to contemporary discussions about the role of religion in public life and the boundaries of scientific authority.

    In addition to philosophical themes, the episode includes accessible anecdotes and case studies. For instance, Stably recounts the historical context surrounding the Protestant Reformation and how it reshaped societal structures, while Jerry adds insights on the influence of classical antiquity on Renaissance humanism. Both hosts emphasize Gillespie’s skill in weaving these diverse threads into a cohesive narrative, making a complex subject engaging and relatable.

    The episode concludes with Jerry and Stably sharing their personal takeaways. They agree that Gillespie’s work challenges readers to reconsider simplistic narratives about modernity’s origins, inviting a deeper appreciation of the interplay between theology, philosophy, and history. As they wrap up, the hosts encourage listeners to reflect on how these historical dynamics continue to shape modern identity and values.

    This discussion offers an intellectually stimulating journey through the intersections of faith, reason, and modernity, underscoring the importance of understanding historical context in making sense of today’s world.

    Show more Show less
    52 mins
  • The Prophets of Doom by Neema Parvini
    Nov 7 2024

    In this episode, Jerry and Stably discuss Prophets of Doom by Neema Parvini, a book that delves into societal power dynamics and the mechanisms by which elites maintain control. The discussion begins with an overview of Parvini’s intellectual background and his previous work on elite theory, which provides a foundation for this latest exploration. Jerry and Stably explain how “Prophets of Doom” builds on these ideas, focusing on the interplay between cultural narratives and elite influence.

    The hosts examine Parvini’s argument that societal elites are not merely individuals in positions of power but members of a cohesive class that perpetuates its dominance through institutional control and manipulation of cultural norms. They explore historical examples and link these ideas to modern-day case studies, providing a robust analysis of how elites shape public discourse to secure their position. Throughout the episode, Jerry and Stably critique and expand on Parvini’s theories, debating their applicability to contemporary political and social issues.

    They also reflect on the broader implications of elite theory, questioning the potential for systemic change and considering whether Parvini’s perspective offers a way to understand recurring societal challenges. The conversation is enriched with anecdotes, personal insights, and recommendations for further exploration, making this episode both thought-provoking and highly relevant for anyone interested in understanding the dynamics of power and influence in society.

    Show more Show less
    43 mins
  • What Went Wrong with Capitalism by Ruchir Sharma
    Oct 22 2024

    The episode focuses on a discussion between Jerry and Stably about Ruchir Sharma’s book What Went Wrong With Capitalism. The hosts delve into the central themes of the book, including the rise of economic inequality, the stagnation of middle-class wages, and the growing influence of monopolies in global markets. Sharma critiques how capitalism, once a system driving innovation and widespread prosperity, has transformed into one that increasingly benefits the few at the expense of the many.

    Jerry and Stably explore Sharma’s argument that unchecked corporate power, political complacency, and a focus on short-term profits have eroded the foundational values of capitalism. They examine specific examples, such as how dominant tech companies have leveraged their market position to stifle competition and innovation. The hosts also discuss the impact of globalization, reflecting on the tensions between free trade and protectionist policies, particularly in the context of economic shifts in countries like the United States and China.

    A notable part of the conversation revolves around Sharma’s proposed solutions to address these systemic issues. These include reinvigorating antitrust enforcement, encouraging grassroots entrepreneurship, and rethinking fiscal policies to balance growth and equality. Stably highlights the practicality of some suggestions while questioning the feasibility of others in the current political climate. Jerry adds a historical perspective, drawing parallels with earlier economic shifts that required structural changes to preserve the benefits of capitalism.

    Throughout the episode, the hosts emphasize the importance of this discussion in the modern era, where economic discontent and political polarization often intersect. They reflect on the book’s relevance to individuals and policymakers alike, underlining its call for a reimagined capitalism that aligns more closely with its original principles of fairness and opportunity.

    By the end of the episode, Jerry and Stably agree that What Went Wrong With Capitalism serves as both a critique and a roadmap, challenging readers to reconsider their assumptions about economic systems while inspiring action to ensure a more equitable future.

    Show more Show less
    53 mins
  • The Case Against Reality by Donald Hoffman
    Sep 26 2024

    The episode features Jerry and Stably discussing the book The Case Against Reality by Donald Hoffman. Jerry introduces the book as a thought-provoking exploration of perception, reality, and consciousness, inspired by a personal recommendation. The hosts delve into Hoffman’s central argument that our perceptions of the world are not objective reflections of reality but evolved constructs designed to maximize survival rather than convey truth.

    The conversation begins with Stably reflecting on the implications of Hoffman’s ideas for everyday experiences, particularly how this perspective challenges intuitive notions about the nature of existence. Jerry provides an overview of Hoffman’s evolutionary game theory model, which suggests that organisms develop perceptions not to understand reality as it is but to create simplified, user-friendly interfaces that guide successful behavior. They discuss examples, including the concept of visual perception as akin to a computer desktop, where icons represent underlying complexities we are not equipped to process directly.

    The hosts also explore how Hoffman’s theories intersect with broader philosophical and scientific debates about consciousness. Jerry highlights the book’s critique of materialism and its argument that consciousness might be fundamental to reality rather than an emergent property of physical systems. Stably raises questions about the implications of this idea, particularly in the context of artificial intelligence and neuroscience, while expressing some skepticism about Hoffman’s conclusions.

    Throughout the episode, the hosts incorporate case studies and analogies from the book to illustrate key points. They examine experiments in perception, such as optical illusions and studies on animal senses, to underscore how different species construct distinct “realities” based on their survival needs. This leads to a broader discussion on the limits of human understanding and the value of embracing uncertainty in scientific inquiry.

    The episode concludes with Jerry and Stably reflecting on how Hoffman’s work inspires a reevaluation of deeply held assumptions about reality. They agree that while the book’s arguments are ambitious and occasionally contentious, its interdisciplinary approach offers a fresh lens through which to examine the relationship between mind, perception, and the nature of existence. Both hosts recommend the book as a challenging but rewarding read for those interested in philosophy, science, and the mysteries of consciousness.

    Show more Show less
    1 hr
  • Losing the Long Game by Philip H. Gordon
    Sep 3 2024

    The episode centers on a discussion of Losing the Long Game: The False Promise of Regime Change in the Middle East by Philip H. Gordon, a book selected by Stably. The hosts examine Gordon’s analysis of the United States’ history of regime change in the Middle East, highlighting the recurring failures of such policies and their often devastating consequences.

    Jerry and Stably explore the core arguments presented in the book, particularly Gordon’s assertion that regime change efforts, while sometimes well-intentioned, have consistently underestimated the complexities of the region and overestimated the ability of external powers to control outcomes. They discuss examples from the book, including interventions in Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, and Syria, using these case studies to illustrate how regime changes have frequently led to instability, human suffering, and unintended geopolitical consequences.

    The hosts focus on Gordon’s critique of the flawed assumptions underpinning these policies, such as the belief that removing a dictator would automatically lead to democratization or that Western-style governance could be imposed on societies with vastly different histories and political structures. They reflect on the role of hubris, ideological bias, and the tendency to prioritize short-term objectives over long-term stability in driving these decisions.

    Stably highlights Gordon’s argument that regime change is often pursued without a coherent plan for the aftermath, leading to power vacuums, insurgencies, and regional chaos. Jerry adds a historical perspective, comparing these modern interventions with earlier examples of imperial overreach and the unintended consequences of foreign meddling. Together, they discuss the broader lessons for policymakers, emphasizing the need for humility, a deeper understanding of local contexts, and a focus on diplomacy over military solutions.

    The episode also addresses some of the criticisms of Gordon’s analysis, including whether the author underestimates the challenges of non-intervention and the moral dilemmas of tolerating oppressive regimes. While the hosts acknowledge these points, they largely agree with Gordon’s thesis that regime change has been a consistently flawed strategy with predictable and avoidable outcomes.

    The discussion concludes with Jerry and Stably reflecting on the broader implications of the book for future U.S. foreign policy. They emphasize Gordon’s call for a more cautious and pragmatic approach, one that prioritizes stability, respect for sovereignty, and the avoidance of overreach. The episode provides a thoughtful examination of the lessons from past failures and a sobering reminder of the complexities of international relations.

    Show more Show less
    1 hr and 6 mins
  • The World That Wasn't by Benn Steil
    Aug 19 2024

    The episode features a discussion of Ben Steil The World That Wasn’t: Henry Wallace and the Fate of the American Century, focusing on the life and legacy of Henry Wallace, a controversial figure in mid-20th century American politics. Jerry and Stably explore the book’s central themes, including Wallace’s vision for a progressive, egalitarian future and the historical forces that ultimately marginalized his ideas.

    Jerry introduces Wallace as a pivotal yet often overlooked figure, detailing his role as Vice President under Franklin D. Roosevelt and his subsequent marginalization by political elites wary of his progressive ideals. The hosts delve into Steil’s portrayal of Wallace as a visionary who sought to reshape the American century into one defined by social justice, economic equality, and international cooperation. Wallace’s advocacy for policies like universal healthcare, anti-racism initiatives, and a more diplomatic approach to foreign relations positioned him as a polarizing figure, especially during the intensifying Cold War.

    Stably emphasizes Steil’s argument that Wallace’s fall from political power was emblematic of a broader shift in American priorities during the mid-20th century. They discuss the forces that opposed Wallace, including conservative Democrats, rising Cold War tensions, and the growing influence of corporate interests. Wallace’s removal from the Roosevelt ticket in 1944, replaced by Harry Truman, is highlighted as a critical turning point, reflecting the Democratic Party’s pivot away from its New Deal roots toward a more centrist stance.

    The hosts also examine Steil’s analysis of Wallace’s enduring relevance, particularly his warnings about the dangers of unchecked capitalism and militarism. They reflect on how Wallace’s ideas, dismissed as radical in his time, resonate in contemporary debates about inequality, climate change, and the role of the United States in global affairs. Jerry points out Steil’s use of archival materials to illuminate Wallace’s intellectual depth and moral clarity, while Stably critiques some of the book’s speculative elements, particularly regarding what might have happened if Wallace’s vision had prevailed.

    Notable examples discussed include Wallace’s advocacy for a postwar international order grounded in cooperation rather than competition, as well as his controversial engagement with Soviet leaders during a time of growing anti-communist sentiment in the U.S. The hosts consider whether Wallace’s idealism was his greatest strength or his fatal flaw, debating the balance between pragmatism and principle in political leadership.

    In closing, Jerry and Stably agree that The World That Wasn’t is a compelling examination of an alternative vision for the American century, offering both a critique of the path taken and a reminder of the possibilities that were left behind. They commend Steil for reviving Wallace’s story and presenting it as a lens through which to consider the challenges and opportunities of shaping a more equitable future.

    Show more Show less
    1 hr and 10 mins
  • The World Beyond Your Head by Matthew B. Crawford
    Jul 25 2024

    The episode centers on a discussion of Matthew B. Crawford’s The World Beyond Your Head: On Becoming an Individual in an Age of Distraction, selected by Stably. The hosts delve into Crawford’s exploration of attention, individuality, and the challenges posed by the modern, hyper-stimulating environment. Jerry and Stably reflect on how the book critiques the pervasive influence of consumer culture and technology on our capacity to focus, connect with others, and engage meaningfully with the world.

    The hosts begin by discussing Crawford’s argument that attention is a finite and increasingly commodified resource, with corporations and digital platforms competing aggressively to capture it. Crawford contends that this environment undermines autonomy and individual agency, as people are pulled away from self-directed thought and immersed in distractions engineered for profit. Stably highlights the book’s critique of the modern emphasis on “choice” as a shallow substitute for true freedom, arguing that our choices are often pre-shaped by systems that prioritize consumption over creativity or reflection.

    Jerry focuses on Crawford’s call to re-engage with tangible, skill-based activities as a way to reclaim attention and rebuild a sense of agency. The hosts discuss examples from the book, including Crawford’s examination of craftspeople, mechanics, and athletes, whose work requires sustained focus and a deep connection to the physical world. These case studies illustrate Crawford’s belief that mastering a skill or trade can provide a counterbalance to the fragmented, superficial nature of modern life.

    The conversation also touches on Crawford’s philosophical influences, including his critique of the Enlightenment ideal of the isolated, self-sufficient individual. Crawford argues that true individuality emerges not in isolation but through engagement with the world and with communities of practice. Stably and Jerry explore how this perspective challenges dominant cultural narratives and resonates with broader debates about the balance between independence and interdependence in contemporary society.

    Throughout the episode, the hosts reflect on the book’s relevance to their own lives and the challenges of maintaining focus in an era defined by constant notifications, advertisements, and information overload. They discuss practical strategies inspired by the book, such as cultivating environments that minimize distractions and prioritizing activities that foster deep attention and meaningful engagement.

    The episode concludes with a reflection on the broader implications of Crawford’s work. Jerry and Stably agree that The World Beyond Your Head offers a compelling critique of modern life while providing a hopeful vision of how individuals can reclaim their attention and agency. They commend Crawford for blending philosophical depth with accessible storytelling, making the book a thought-provoking read for anyone grappling with the demands of the digital age.

    Show more Show less
    57 mins
  • The United States of Paranoia by Jesse Walker
    Jul 8 2024

    In this episode we discuss The United States of Paranoia: A Conspiracy Theory by Jesse Walker. Next time we will discuss Everything Was Forever, Until It Was No More: The Last Soviet Generation by Alexei Yurchak.

    Show more Show less
    1 hr and 18 mins