Episodes

  • Substance without Substance - House of Death, NYC, NY
    Mar 8 2022

    This week we are telling a tale of the city that doesn't sleep, New York City! A little brownstone house is a home to quite a few ghosts, and all of them have a story to tell. Especially Mark Twain.  BONUS! Peter's computer becomes possessed.

    Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
    Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

    Go to the arcade and play FREE games on Steam or at Itch.io.

    Find us on Instagram @CreepyPizzaPodcast
    And on Twitter @CreepyPizza1

    Want to support the show? Be a Pizza Pal on Patreon, or if you don't like commitment, buy us a slice here! 

    Support the show
    Show more Show less
    59 mins
  • Don't Bet Against the House - Muriel's New Orleans. LA
    Mar 1 2022

    It's Mardi Gras! Let's drink up with a glass-smashing party ghost and have a seance in a poker-player ghost's fixer up.  We're off to Louisiana to New Orleans' infamous Muriel's Jackson Square to meet some spirits that still hang around this haunt.

    Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
    Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

    Go to the arcade and play FREE games on Steam or at Itch.io.

    Find us on Instagram @CreepyPizzaPodcast
    And on Twitter @CreepyPizza1

    Want to support the show? Be a Pizza Pal on Patreon, or if you don't like commitment, buy us a slice here! 

    Support the show
    Show more Show less
    38 mins
  • Wet 'n' Weird Water Monsters - TOP TEN
    Feb 22 2022

    This week we hit the big 50! Let's count down the wildest, wettest, weirdest, water cryptids in this world! We are also releasing a bonus bite on Patreon this week! 

    Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
    Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

    Go to the arcade and play FREE games on Steam or at Itch.io.

    Find us on Instagram @CreepyPizzaPodcast
    And on Twitter @CreepyPizza1

    Want to support the show? Be a Pizza Pal on Patreon, or if you don't like commitment, buy us a slice here! 

    Support the show
    Show more Show less
    42 mins
  • Boston Scream Pie - The ghosts of the Omni Parker Hotel
    Feb 15 2022

    This week we head to Boston, MA to learn about the spooky happenings of the Omni Parker House Hotel. There is a crazy cast of famous guests who have checked in, and some never checked out.

    Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
    Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

    Go to the arcade and play FREE games on Steam or at Itch.io.

    Find us on Instagram @CreepyPizzaPodcast
    And on Twitter @CreepyPizza1

    Want to support the show? Be a Pizza Pal on Patreon, or if you don't like commitment, buy us a slice here! 

    Support the show
    Show more Show less
    44 mins
  • Ohio is for Loveland Frogman
    Feb 8 2022

    Hey there
    This week we introduce you to the Loveland Frogman, a cryptid from Loveland Ohio that might have actually just been Peter in a frog costume. We (sort of) answer the questions like: "did vacuums lead to feminism?" and "what is the difference between a frogman and a lizardman?" Grab your banjo, swoop your bangs, and sit down for a slice of Creepy Pizza.

    Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
    Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

    Go to the arcade and play FREE games on Steam or at Itch.io.

    Find us on Instagram @CreepyPizzaPodcast
    And on Twitter @CreepyPizza1

    Want to support the show? Be a Pizza Pal on Patreon, or if you don't like commitment, buy us a slice here! 

    Support the show
    Show more Show less
    44 mins
  • Goat Cheesy Breadsticks, Brigid On! Imbolc History and Faerie Folklore
    Feb 1 2022

    Let's pour some milk out for our homies and learn about the history and traditions of Imbolc. We learn about a goddess that should be your role model, what latitudes are, how the groundhog stole all the fame, and some faerie folklore. Need a reason to spring clean? Imbolc. Need a reason to celebrate the end of Dry January? Imbolc.

    Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
    Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

    Go to the arcade and play FREE games on Steam or at Itch.io.

    Find us on Instagram @CreepyPizzaPodcast
    And on Twitter @CreepyPizza1

    Want to support the show? Be a Pizza Pal on Patreon, or if you don't like commitment, buy us a slice here!

    Support the show
    Show more Show less
    47 mins
  • The Furniture Refurbisher and the Martini Demon - The Dybbuk Box
    Jan 25 2022

    This week listen to Britt wine to Peter about a demonic piece of furniture, The Dybbuk Box. Be careful what you're regifting after the holidays, it just might be possessed. 

    Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
    Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

    Go to the arcade and play FREE games on Steam or at Itch.io.

    Find us on Instagram @CreepyPizzaPodcast
    And on Twitter @CreepyPizza1

    Want to support the show? Be a Pizza Pal on Patreon, or if you don't like commitment, buy us a slice here!


    Support the show
    Show more Show less
    54 mins
  • The Demon of the Opera: Frederick Federici and the Princess Theater
    Jan 18 2022

    This week Britt takes Peter back to Australia for an exciting tale that will get your heart racing. We learn about the questionable career choices of Frederick Federici and the history of Melbourne's beautiful Princess Theater. We also try to speak with an Aussie accent and fail miserably, mate. At least Britt has her favorite mug.

    Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com
    Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com

    Go to the arcade and play FREE games on Steam or at Itch.io.

    Find us on Instagram @CreepyPizzaPodcast
    And on Twitter @CreepyPizza1

    Want to support the show? Be a Pizza Pal on Patreon, or if you don't like commitment, buy us a slice here!


    Support the show
    Show more Show less
    37 mins