Under the Greenwood Tree

By: Thomas Hardy

Narrated by: Simon Vance

One of the most popular of Hardy's novels, this charming pastoral idyll is a lightly humorous depiction of life in an early Victorian rural community. Drawn from Hardy's childhood memories, it represents, he said, "a true picture at first hand of the personages, ways, and customs which were common in the villages."

The story delicately balances the concerns of the Mellstock parish choir with a romance between Dick Dewy, a member of the choir, and Fancy Day, the village schoolmistress. While the choir battles for its survival against the new vicar's mechanical church organ, personal conflicts arise over the anachronistic customs of tradition.

Public Domain (P)2018 Blackstone Audio, Inc.

Critic reviews

"It bubbles with good humor and joy in living." (James Gibson, Thomas Hardy: A Literary Life)

Hardy without the tragedy

This story is a bit more straightforward than Hardy’s later novels but still retains his detail and style.

Classic humour

Sheer delight to listen to this classic with Simon Vance's gentle and sharp narration of the nuances.

I didn't love the main characters

I felt like Dick and Fanny were both unlikable characters. Fanny was silly and shallow and in the beginning I felt like Dick did some disrespectful things. For example, in one scene he accidentally placed his hand on Fanny's at a dinner party when they barely knew each other and then left it there, which put Fanny in a very awkward situation with the public setting. It felt like he was using the setting to take advantage of her. Other than than my bleh feelings about these two, the book was entertaining enough.

One of Hardy’s Best

Hardy knows how to serve a love story around a village. This is no exception.

Happy surprise!

I was looking for something that would make me smile during these times and I wasn't expecting it from Thomas Hardy. I recently tried to reread Tess and had to put it back down.. Almost from the get-go the dialog had me grinning and giggling. I needed a story without angst.. The characterizations by the narrator were wonderful and so full of fun.

A very good audiobook

This Hardy novel was on the light side, unlike his other novels, this one was by far the most cheerful.

Light & lovely

A sweet little tale of romance and village life in early nineteenth century England.

I have a problem with the narrator.

His voice is so soothing that I often found myself drifting away in meditation instead of paying attention.
Thankfully the story compliments this reading, as it is light, and filled with general wisdoms and situations.
I might re-listen to this book, simply because it is so pleasant. At times reminiscent of J. R. R. Tolkein's Shire.

Under the Greenwood tree

I had a bit of trouble understanding the dialogue because of the heavy accents of the characters, but I managed. this lovely story was romantic. I listened to the audio book version and enjoyed it.

A Lighter Hardy

A charming novel set in the Yorkshire countryside, devoid of the usual darkness typical of other Hardy novels, such as Jude the Obscure, Tess of the D'Urbervilles, Far from the Madding Crowd, and others. As always, his characters are well rounded, displaying very human flaws that make them all the more endearing. Fancy Day, despite her love for Dick Dewey, can't resist flattery and a chance to show herself off; Dick himself has a bit of a jealous streak. But overall, Hardy creates that wonderful sense of community and slower-paced days that we seem to long for in our times.