Turning the Black Sox White

The Misunderstood Legacy of Charles A. Comiskey

By: Tim Hornbaker

Narrated by: Stephen Hoye

Charles Albert “The Old Roman” Comiskey was a larger-than-life figure - a man who had precision in his speech and who could work a room with handshakes and smiles. While he has been vilified in film as a rotund cheapskate and the driving force, albeit unknowingly, behind the actions of the 1919 White Sox, who threw the World Series (nicknamed the “Black Sox” scandal), that statement is far from the truth.

In his five decades involved in baseball, Comiskey loved the sport through and through. It was his passion, his life blood, and once he was able to combine his love for the game with his managerial skills, it was the complete package for him. There was no other alternative. He brought the White Sox to Chicago in 1900 and was a major influential force in running the American League from its inception. From changing the way the first base position was played, to spreading the concept of “small ball” as a manager, to incorporating the community in his team’s persona while he was an owner, Comiskey’s style and knowledge improved the overall standard for how baseball should be played.

Through rigorous research from the National Archives, newspapers, and various other publications, Tim Hornbaker not only tells the full story of Comiskey’s incredible life and the sport at the time, but also debunks the “Black Sox” controversy, showing that Comiskey was not the reason that the Sox threw the 1919 World Series.

©2014 Tim Hornbaker. Foreword © 2014 by Bob Hoie (P)2014 Audible, Inc.

Decent book on a baseball pioneer

Pretty good biography of Charles Comiskey - covers much more than just his ownership of the White Sox. It had MUCH more information than I bargained for, such as his long playing career in Minnesota (St. Paul) before becoming an owner. The biggest disappointment I had was that the foreword gave some very juicy information about refuting many of the claims of how much of a cheapskate Comiskey was, the popular theory behind why the White Sox "Eight Men Out" threw the 1919 World Series. Everything from the real story behind Eddie Cicotte's bonus to Comiskey's generosity was previewed - then never mentioned again until late in the book. By then, the reader heard SO much information on Comiskey that the original points that would interest the reader may have been forgotten, which was the case with me. But because the book is well researched and Comiskey's complete life is illustrated, it gets a passing grade from me.

And he walked on water ….

Read the Forward. Read the last chapter. Everything else is nonsense. Not that it could be true, but mostly because they are disconnected. I think the author needs to go back to writing about wrasslin’.

The narrator has a condescending tone/attitude which is very annoying