The Decagon House Murders

De: Yukito Ayatsuji, Ho-Ling Wong - translator

Narrado por: P.J. Ochlan

A hugely enjoyable, must-listen murder mystery sure to appeal to fans of Elly Griffiths, Anthony Horowitz, and Agatha Christie, with one of the best and most satisfying conclusions you'll ever hear. A classic in Japan, available in English for the first time.

©2007 Yukito Auatsuji (P)2022 Tantor

Guessing game

Okay so I had to reread the first chapter to understand everyone’s role . As you get deeper in the storyline it starts to get interesting. Now you’re guessing who is clever enough to to do all these murders without leaving clues of who might have done it. While pointing fingers and being divided they lose focus on what they are really there for. Great read

Narrator ruined the book

The narrator constantly put the wrong emPHAsis on the wrong syLLAble in words. Lol. It was just weird and ruined the audio book.

Awful narration from P.J. Ochlan!

Many reviewers have already commented about P.J. Ochlan's terrible narration and I couldn't agree more. He truly RUINED this book for me. Please read it instead.

Good Story, Not Good Narration

There appear to be plenty of reviews about the narration, and it was definitely jarring whenever they missed the inflection for a word.

This book definitely takes some notes from "And Then There Were None" beyond the actual reference. I enjoyed the end reveal, and the ending. It didn't, however, leave me thinking the villain was an evil genius, which I was hoping for. Instead, it felt more that they were extraordinarily lucky (e.g. Uncle buys the property and tells me all about it, etc.). I also felt like some of the characters could've used a little more fleshing out. However, it was ultimately, despite my gripes and the narration, a thoroughly enjoyable story.

3 out of 5

the story was alright but the reader was stiff and robotic. his reading was very strange. I have listened to some terrible audio recordings in the past but still loved the book because in the end it was still a great story. this was not one of those times unfortunately. the story was just alright and for a book I've seen on multiple lists for one of the best mysteries of all time I was disappointed. mind you, this is just my opinion and if someone was to ask me "should I give this book a read?" is say yes because it wasn't bad by any means. I just didn't love it.

Clever enough, but marred by narration

Appreciated the mystery-for-mystery-nerds references and plotting, but for me, the paper-thin character development was a negative (and I’m a fan of this subgenre, so I’m willing to forgive a lot on that front). The denouement was somewhat unsatisfying for me since it felt like establishment of credible motivation had been sacrificed to “surprise” plot twists, with an internal monologue bad-guy-speech trying to paper over the holes at the end.

However, the biggest challenge for me was the narrator’s performance. He chose to deliver all the third-person narration in a strongly repetitive, lilting, and artificial cadence I associate with local news broadcasters. I found it quite grating, and it frankly ruined the more atmospheric moments for me.

For readers who might want to know: this novel does not rise above its origin time period and cultural milieu, so expect pervasive casual misogyny.

It was a fun story!

I thought it was fun. Kept me interested from start to finish. It was a new fun twist of a murder story.

Good story, bad narration

I liked the story but couldn’t get past the bad narration. I recommend reading rather than listening.

Story great but narrator awful

Unfortunately the narrator really detracted from the audiobook. Great story but really let down by the narrator who has a very robotic and stilted style. I

Narration is awful

The book is wonderful, but the narrator sounds robotic and bizarre, which made it hard to listen to