Red Cat

A John March Novel

By: Peter Spiegelman

Narrated by: Elliott Gould

With a troubled past and a job that attracts too much attention from the law, private investigator John March has always been the black sheep of his merchant banking family—which makes the identity of his latest client all the more surprising: his smug older brother.

David March has been having affairs with anonymous women he meets on the internet, and now one of these women is stalking him. David knows her only as Wren. She, however, knows everything about David—and she's threatening to tell his wife and colleagues, ruining his life.

But after Wren turns up dead, John finds he's no longer searching for a stalker—now he's looking for a murderer, and the clues keep leading him back to his older brother's doorstep.

©2007 Peter Spiegelman (P)2022 Phoenix Books

Brilliant story • 4.5 Stars • Major talent but...

Peter Spiegelman took my breath away. He as insightful re. this moment's human nature as the American classic writers of the 30s and 40s. He may be even better in the sense that he creates insights so believable that you are forced to rethink the nature of human relationships. Yeah, it is a dark and ADULT novel. Yes there is sex, but... but... it is essential to this psycho/social/cultural exploration. Oh... and he writes with the craft of a great surgeon. However art without wonder is merely craft... And The Red Cat leaves you with wonderings that nag.

So... I can understand why the publishers felt that this novel was sufficiently important to snag a celebrity reader. Eliot Gould may be past his greatness. Or he may have phoned in at least some of his reading. But what's inescapably true is that the production people failed both Gould and Spiegelman by leaving a debris of seemingly random and maddening pauses behind. However, the story and Gould's adequate presentation of it overcome and this is a mystery which does not fall apart at its end. The characters will haunt you because they are complex and naggingly familiar.

Red Cat is worth the money, the time, and the feelings it provokes. Four and a half stars!!!

I agree with good book/bad reader

I usually just rate books on the library page but I thought this one deserved a written review in case the author might see it. I love the book as I do many series characters...with Spenser being the very high standard...but Elliott Gould just butchered this book. Huge number of acCENTS on the wrong SyllAHble etc. Still gets 3 stars for the story. AND the production values were horrible. Huge distraction to have the 'tape recorder' go on and off mid-paragraph. Barely worth it as is...but if you ,like I still do, read some books on paper I'd put this one in that queue.

good book bad narrator

I don't know what to think of this audio book, I mean I like the author and I think the John March series are pretty good; and the book is not bad but the narrator made it really hard to listen to. His voice is too old and too monotone, nasal and basically boring. To me half the fun of listening to a book is the narrator injecting life into the story and characters and after Scott Brick (which I think is one of the best narrator out there) reading the first book of the series, this narrator didn't cut it for me.

In spite of the other reviewers....

I very much enjoyed Gould's reading of this artsy noir detective story--instead of trying inject emotion or attitude, Gould wisely lets the words do the work and the story builds on its own worth, which is considerable. If you're a big fan of Scott Brick, you'll disagree. Nothing more obnoxious than the unsubtle sound of an actor acting. Gould plays it close to the chest, which, for a novel in the tradition of Chandler and Hammett, is exactly what you must do.

Red Cat

I have to agree with the previous listeners--Elliot Gould and the producer butchered this book. There were too many long pauses and mispronounced words. The reading was stilted and unimaginative. Too bad because I really like Peter Spiegelman's books.

Narrator problems!

This was the first story I had bought from this author and I have to agree with the other reviews, the story was good, but Elliott Gould butchered the reading, pauses in the wrong place, extra long pauses, mispronouncing of words, etc. I would definitely buy from this author again but not if Elliott Gould is the narrator.

Good book, bad reader

I have listened to hundreds of audiobooks, and am dismayed to say that Elliott Gould, an actor of bigger reputation than most of the audiobook readers I have become such a fan of, is an awful, monotonous, word-mispronouncing reader! The production on this book is terrible, also, with big silent gaps between, apparently, recording sessions. This is especially frustrating because the Peter Spiegelman book is really good. Was this a rush job or what?

Worst Narration in the World

I am a couple of hours into this book and would rather poke myself in the eye with a rusty poker then listen to Elliot Gould for another moment. The story itslf is engaging and intelligent but good God, Elliot Gould sounds like he is either on drugs or is just learning to read.

Breathy reader.

Reader stops reading and you wonder if there is something wrong with your Ipod; characters didn't build any rapport with me; I didn't care what happened to any of them. Save your credit. I only "bought" this because one of the "great authors" recommended it. Not a book I will think about again!

Poor Production Quality Diminishes a Strong Plot

Phoenix Audio's production of Peter Spiegelman's Red Cat diminishes the pleasure of listening to the sequel to Speiegelman's Black Maps.

The narration by Elliot Gould is clumsy and does little to service the strong, dark plot. As a fan of Gould's television and film work, I was sorely tried by his laborious pacing, oddly accented characterizations and stumbling pronunciations.

Worse, still is the poor production quality of the recording. The lackadaisical editing results in numerous overly long pauses in dialog or narration, distasteful breath and mouth sounds from the narrator and annoying stretches of crackling static. Unforgiveable.

Given Scott Brick's superb reading of Black Maps, produced by Books on Tape, it's difficult to understand the switch to Phoenix for Red Cat.

Although I would recommend Spiegelman's work to any fan of the modern noir thriller, and do so enthusiastically in the case of Brick's Black Maps reading, frankly, I would suggest they pass up this Red Cat production and read the book instead.