Don Quixote

Translated by Edith Grossman

De: Edith Grossman - translator, Miguel de Cervantes

Narrado por: George Guidall

Don Quixote is the classic story. Called the first modern novel, this marvelous book has stood the test of time to become irrevocably intertwined with the fabric of society. Sixteenth-century Spanish gentleman Don Quixote, fed by his own delusional fantasies, takes to the road in search of chivalrous adventures. But his quest leads to more trouble than triumph. At once humorous, romantic, and sad, Don Quixote is a literary landmark. This fresh edition, by award-winning translator Edith Grossman, brings the tale to life as never before.

©2003 Edith Grossman (translation) (P)2003 Recorded Books

Funny and sweet masterpiece

It is a pleasure to listen to this fantastic tale about human nature; Sancho and Don Quixote are all of us. Take your pick about the perspective you want to use while listening to this tale: is it an essay about the human condition, a philosophical treaty,a magnificent allegory or a funny, gentle dialog about human weakness ?

Rarest of Gems: Comedy/Tragedy in Equal Measures

Rare is the story that works well as simultaneously a comedy and a tragedy. Come to think of it, I don't recall reading or seeing so brilliant a comedy/tragedy in a novel or film (I admit my knowledge of theatre is sorely lacking). The only one that comes to mind that most closely approaches Don Quixote, though still miles below it, was the film version of Forrest Gump.

Like Don Quixote, Forrest Gump is episodic in nature, the story progressing through sketches over time, many of them humorous with at least two tragic threads tying them all together: society would always exploit, but was never going to accept, a slow-witted man despite the fact that he was such a significant participant in history and, though Jenny loved Forrest, she would not accept him as her lover and mate until she was nearing death, raising a son of which he had no idea, conceived in their one sexual encounter. Flashback to 1994:

". . .You died on a Saturday mornin.' And I had you placed here under our elm tree. And I had that house of your father's bulldozed to the ground.... I miss you Jenny. If there's anything you need, I won't be far away."

I came late to Don Quixote, only reading it a couple of years ago. As most everyone knows, the novel follows the misadventures of Alonso Quixano, an idealistic hidalgo who has absorbed every known book of chivalry, which he describes as giving him an expertise on knight-errantry including the deeds, holdings, history and general character of each knight ever recorded. He believes himself to be a valorous knight-errant whose name is Don Quixote de la Mancha and sets out to right all wrongs, revitalize chivalry and live out a noble's narrative.

One cannot doubt that today Don Quixote would be committed at least temporarily as a danger to himself and/or others for analysis and treatment of potential mental disorders. He thought windmills were giants, sheep enemy soldiers and fell in love with "Dulcinea del Toboso," whom he describes as a vestal maiden with rosy cheeks, alabaster skin and flowing hair when she was in reality a strapping peasant woman named Aldonza Lorenzo who has barely acknowledged Don Quixote.

Don Quixote's "faithful squire" Sancho Panza calls him the "Knight of the Woeful Countenance." Sancho accompanies Don Quixote for most of the trip suggesting pragmatic, logical options in lieu of Quixote's fantasies unbound by reality. The droll and portly man is full of common sense but has not a grain of spirituality. He provides some comic relief by dropping pithy epigrams, such as "he who's down one day can be up the next, unless he really wants to stay in bed, that is...." He also acts as a "sanity check" on Quixote's world of whimsy. ("Is it possible that your grace is so thickheaded and so short on brains that you cannot see that what I'm telling you is the absolute truth?”).

Don Quixote is filled with hilarity but tinged always with the tragedy borne of sympathy for this man who is ridiculed and played jokes on by people who care not one wit how it might hurt him, for this man who faces long odds and tries and tries and is bound to fall ultimately under the weight of a society, then and now, which did and will not tolerate people who deviate so far from accepted norms; and, the tragic fact that the idealism of nobility and chivalry of centuries ago are no longer nearly as important (and haven't been since at least the early 1600s).

Despite its tragic elements, the novel contains some of the funniest scenes in all of literature. In a way, and what I found most surprising in reading this classic is, the humor is nearly timeless. I've seen dozens and dozens of bits in comedy films and television shows and comic skits that are in some way derivative of the classic comedy and satire of Don Quixote.

Cervantes' paradoxical question seems to be whether it is better to view the world as it is or as it should be? Artist types would say the latter. Kafka said, for example, "Don Quixote's misfortune is not his imagination, but Sancho Panza." Emily Dickinson wrote, "Much madness is the divinest sense."

I sometimes fall into the camp of Kafka, Dickinson and Quixote, when I get to thinking how the world (and life) is sometimes just too damn sad not to block out some reality.

Then I ponder, am I so different than most today? Why do we love reading novels of other worlds and times for which we must temporarily suspend our disbelief (a form of momentary, voluntary madness) hours on end to enjoy the story, why watch movies in which we get to live a different life in the mind for a couple of hours, why root for a sports team playing a game in which we have no *rational* interest in the outcome?

Why, we value escapism and temporary madness so much that many of today's mythical figures in society's eyes are entertainment icons, media stars and sports heroes! But, I digress....

The Infamous Don Quixote

Great narration, and although I cannot compare translations to another version, I thoroughly enjoyed it (yes you can notice some sections originating from another language, but that's part of the experience.
I didn't realize this had the original and sequel in it and was pleasantly surprised when I found out.
Good strange adventurous listen.

A true pleasure

This book is the personification of a classic and should be enjoyed by all. This was one of the most enjoyable and well performed audio books I have listened to and one I have no reservations in recommending to others.

This book will make you laugh and cry - READ IT!

Any additional comments?

At almost a thousand pages of small type, this book is no lightweight undertaking - literally. This book was my end-of-year bridge, spanning three months of fairly consistent and persistent effort.
However, despite its heft it is a romp - a tender exploration of sanity, happiness, and all that makes one human - loyalty, respectfulness, truthfulness, compassion. Senor Quixote's exploits are famous, and rightly so. But what the cartoonish depictions fail to capture is the gentlemanly gentle-ness of his character, and his unabashed zeal for life. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and will be re-reading it soon. Hopefully I will be able to rope my three sons into joining me on the next go round with Don Quixote of La Mancha!

Surprising

I was surprised by how much I enjoyed this old work. The narrator was also excellent. I’ve enjoyed other books he’s read. I have become a fan of Don Quixote and his hysterical squire, Sancho Panza.

Hilarious story, read by a lively narrator.

It's a very funny story, but a bit overwhelming to read. It's nice to put the book down and listen to a few chapters here and there. This reader was so well suited to the material, I continued to hear his voice when I was reading the book myself.

So much better than the Cliff Notes version I read

Great story. No wonder we were supposed to read this in high school! this story has great characters, you can't help but love the key characters. The author, Miguel de Cervantes weaved an enlightening tale of the time circa 1605. Our hero was a little crazy yet brilliant, with a marvelous gift to communicate with grace to any class of people. Don Quixote was also fluent in six or seven languages. Miguel de Cervantes was a master of weaving comedic tone.

Definitely not what I expected but good

I'll probably not going to read this second time, though story was very much amusing at times. I knew nothing of Don Quixote except it was a classic story, and when plot revealed, I was somewhat disappointed. But I think author did amazing job developing characters... Good read overall

What can you say?

Narration was fantastic. I can't imagine how long it would take to actually record this whole book onto audio. Either way, the narrator did a wonderful job. I have read the hard copy of Don Quixote once and his voices are pretty much exactly what I thought the characters would sound like.