Any Other Family

De: Eleanor Brown

Narrado por: Brittany Pressley, Lindsey Dorcus, Sean Patrick Hopkins, Soneela Nankani, Anthony Rey Perez, Thérèse Plummer, Jamil Schulze

A New York Times Book Review Editors' Choice

The New York Times bestselling author of The Weird Sisters returns with a striking and intimate new novel about three very different adoptive mothers who face the impossible question: What makes a family?

Though they look like any other family, they aren’t one—not quite. They are three sets of parents who find themselves intertwined after adopting four biological siblings, having committed to keeping the children as connected as possible.

At the heart of the family, the adoptive mothers grapple to define themselves and their new roles. Tabitha, who adopted the twins, crowns herself planner of the group, responsible for endless playdates and holidays, determined to create a perfect happy family. Quiet and steady Ginger, single mother to the eldest daughter, is wary of the way these complicated not-fully-family relationships test her long held boundaries. And Elizabeth, still reeling from rounds of failed IVF, is terrified that her unhappiness after adopting a newborn means she was not meant to be a mother at all.

As they set out on their first family vacation, all three are pushed into uncomfortably close quarters. And when they receive a call from their children’s birth mother announcing she is pregnant again, the delicate bonds the women are struggling to form threaten to collapse as they each must consider how a family is found and formed.

©2022 Eleanor Brown (P)2022 Penguin Audio

Reseñas de la Crítica

One of:
Real Simple's Best Books of 2022
Southern Livings’s Beach Reads Perfect for Summer 2022
Entertainment Weekly’s 16 Novels We’re Excited for This Summer

"A tearjerker that nails the issues of fertility, adopton, and raising kids, this is a conversation starter about parenthood you don't want to miss." –Real Simple

“[A] treat of a novel…[Brown] examines the pressures placed on mothers while considering what makes a family and comes up with a wonderful answer: commitment and love.” –Minneapolis Star Tribune

“Brown explores the meaning of motherhood and the limits of a blended family in her vivid character study of four biological siblings adopted by three sets of parents, set across the span of a single (and singular) vacation.” –Entertainment Weekly

Family

Eye opener for the struggles of infertility and dynamics of adoption.
Keeping family a priority.

A blended family

Would have loved a review from the children when they were grown. Was this a good thing for them?Or a confusing thing for Them.

Good book. disappointing ending.

Good book on non-traditional families and adoption. My own family has our adopted daughter and we are friends with the other adoptive family who adopted her biological sister and brother so it was great to see this scenario in a novel. Also Elizabeth's infertility struggles hit home for me and the author does a great job with the truth of her infertility story. The performance of each woman's chapters were also well done. I just was really disappointed with the ending and unanswered questions.

What is family?

This story attempts to answer the question of what makes a family, and does it quite well. All narrators are excellent, with Brittany's performance being a stand out among the rest. A great cast of characters as well.

Very inventive story.

You like then dislike most of the women then like again. All the men are great. The story is about open adoption with a very inventive twist.

fascinating approach to open adoption

slow engagement initially and well worth my time and patience! interesting characters and universal parenting challenges.

A true gift

Eleanor Brown has done a phenomenal job painting a nuanced picture of motherhood while asking with what it means to be a family. I was taken back to my days as a young mother with more compassion for myself in those difficult years.

highly recommend!

great writing, amazing narration, and a great novel for those who are & who are not a part of adoption

The characters are hard for me to like …

I am a bit past the halfway point of this audio book. I do not like any of the characters and this has never happened to me before. In 5 hours, 55 minutes, and 19 seconds, no character has earned my praise. Your choices are the Enabler, the Victim, the Whiner, the Passive-Agressor, and the Judge; then you have the men. The children, at least thus far, are bit players. Finally, in the last five minutes of listening before arriving home, one of the husbands began to show promise, so maybe there is hope. And the whole concept of THE FAMILY is just frightening. This is what a systems therapist would call a fused emotional mass. I am going to continue on toward the end and then add to the review, but just needed to unload a bit.

What is a family?

Although I am an ardent fiction reader, I do read to learn; empathy is something I have gained through reading. Learning about different cultures, even in a fictional story, is a way to learn. In “Any Other Family”, which explores families, what it means to be a family, and open adoptions and family, I learned more than I expected. Author Eleanor Brown sneaks in the overwhelming emotions that lead to adoption, mostly infertility, the years and years of infertility and the heartbreaking losses of miscarriages. This sounds like a sad, miserable story, but it is not. Brown deftly adds humor and human hijinks to the story. Three families connected by their children who embark on a two-week family vacation! What could possibly go wrong? Think of your family vacations with just one set of parents, now there are three, not including the birth mother. Can you say “Forced Family Fun?”

“They look like any other family,” Brown writes. “They are a family formed by three sets of parents who adopted from the same group of biological siblings.”

Brianna, the birth mother, had one child and realized she could not take care of her. She decided to place her child up for adoption, with the caveat that it’s open. The adoptive parent agreed. Brianna chose her child’s preschool teacher; it was easy. And then, Brianna finds herself pregnant again! With twins! She finds a couple who agree to the open adoption and to include the other family in important family events. The mother of the twins, Tabitha, is an organizer. She takes control of the family events, birthday parties, holidays, occasional Sunday dinners. Brianna gets pregnant again. It is Tabitha who finds a family for the fourth child. Tabitha arranges this 2-week family vacation for all three families which now total four siblings. Brianna is to attend the family vacation, and calls in last minute, saying she cannot make it because, surprise! She’s pregnant….again.

Brianna, whom Brown spends little time on developing her character, is almost a side note. Brown never addresses how this woman can irresponsibly keep getting pregnant when she knows she cannot take care of her children. Plus, she makes the parents of her children find the other parents. She cannot be bothered. This irresponsibility is not addressed well, for me anyway. The oldest child is entering middle school. The youngest is still an infant.

I believe Brown had Brianna pass her responsibility of finding adoptive parents so that she could show in the story the sadness of the families who want to adopt. How she did that is through brief interludes of letters from prospective parents. Through the letters the reader feels the emotional rollercoaster of people wanting to adopt.

Each mother has her own chapter, providing alternating perspectives, and we learn their inner thoughts, fears, strengths, and dreams. Brown writes them with attention and kindness showing their humanity. We learn of the highly relatable complexities and nuances of each character. Even bossy Tabitha, the mother hen, we learn of her true intentions, and she becomes more relatable and enduring.

“How odd that they came on vacation only to feel further apart from each other. When she thinks of how close she hoped they would all become during these weeks together, she doesn’t know whether to laugh or cry.”

In her Author’s Note, Brown informs the reader that she is an adoptive mother of a son. She intended to write a story of adoption exploring all the variables involved in adoptions. She’s an advocate of adoption and wanted to show how adoptive families choose to structure their families. She also showcased the emotional journey parents must go through to get to the decision to adopt. She admitted that she could not address all complexities of adoption in one story, and this is NOT a story of all adoptions.

I chose to listen to the audio, narrated by Brittany Pressley and 8 others who read the letters of prospective adoptive parents. The audio was done very well.

Motherhood and blended families are highlighted here. This is a story of family, made by choice, with the ideal of healthy, grounded children as the main intention.