The Unidentified

Mythical Monsters, Alien Encounters, and Our Obsession with the Unexplained

De: Colin Dickey

Narrado por: Will Damron

"Absolutely perfect for the current moment." (BuzzFeed)

America's favorite cultural historian and author of Ghostland takes a tour of the country's most persistent "unexplained" phenomena.

In a world where rational, scientific explanations are more available than ever, belief in the unprovable and irrational - in fringe - is on the rise: from Atlantis to aliens, from Flat Earth to the Loch Ness monster, the list goes on. It seems the more our maps of the known world get filled in, the more we crave mysterious locations full of strange creatures.

Enter Colin Dickey, cultural historian and tour guide of the weird. With the same curiosity and insight that made Ghostland a hit with readers and critics, Colin looks at what all fringe beliefs have in common, explaining that today's Illuminati is yesterday's Flat Earth: the attempt to find meaning in a world stripped of wonder. Dickey visits the wacky sites of America's wildest fringe beliefs - from the famed Mount Shasta where the ancient race (or extraterrestrials, or possibly both, depending on who you ask) called Lemurians are said to roam, to the museum containing the last remaining "evidence" of the great Kentucky meat shower - investigating how these theories come about, why they take hold, and why as Americans we keep inventing and reinventing them decade after decade. The Unidentified is Colin Dickey at his best: curious, wry, brilliant in his analysis, yet eminently engaging.

©2020 Colin Dickey (P)2020 Penguin Audio

Well-trodden ground

More hand-wringing about beliefs in the paranormal. While Dickey examines a diverse array of Fortean topics, his analysis often feels like a Sociology 101 cliche: Bigfoot is about a post-war crisis of masculinity; the paranormal reflects a primitive desire to experience magic and wonder; believers are deluded or malicious. Virtually every paranormal experiencer has heard these arguments yet most remain steadfast in their beliefs and Dickey fails to provide fresh insights as to why this is. Absent also is a comprehensive analysis of the other side of this intellectual battle, namely the culture of debunkers and skeptics. This faction, in their eagerness to disprove the paranormal, often posit their own dubious or absurd theories that lack scientific merit. So what pathologies and prejudices drive them? How is the "scientific community" itself sometimes a victim of its own politics and groupthink? So much of our current culture wars are between believers and skeptics so a deep analysis of current events requires stepping back from both sides and examining the interplay between them. In selecting one side over the other, however, Dickey failed to fully comprehend the bigger picture.

Amazing

The writing and the narration. Everything was amazing. Filled with info and incidents.
Every chapter was informative. Many of the incidents are new to me, and I like that the writer wllows for both sides of the story to be presented.

One of the best sociological explanations

The text is honest in its approach, agnostic in its conclusions, and tactful in its discussion. If you find you have a knee jerk reaction, you will have revealed one of your biases. Listen until the end; it is totally worth it.

a lighthearted but critical look at modern legends

I am a skeptic who can't help but be drawn to stories of high strangeness, even if I don't necessarily believe any of them.

This book is great for people in or around that mindset as it goes into more of the "why" our society perpetuates these stories and why some even still take them as gospel.

It does provide a critical look at the flaws, fabrications and ridiculousness of these tales but the author seems to be coming from a place of "loving cynicism" while doing so.

admittedly my only real gripe is a selfish one in that I wish more time was spent retelling the myths and stories although I don't believe that was the main point of the book.

all in all this book is great for both believers and skeptics that have a mutual interest or curiosity in cryptids, UFOs and other paranormal strangeness

The author is a skeptic no matter what

Most people would choose to listen to a book like this because of the wonder and lore that the existence of cryptid creatures may be real. This author seems to ignore that fact, and denies any and all possibility of said Cryptids existence whatsoever. I get the feeling the author could spend an entire month in the company of a Bigfoot, and still tell his readers that there is no way to believe Sasquatch is anything more than a myth.

Great Narration

The narrator is great, but the writing style of this book was a bit boring. I nearly returned it because it was so dry, but the content itself is interesting if you stick with it.

As presumptive in its own conclusions as it claims others are in theirs.

Seems not very ballanced with point and counterpoint explanations. This book seems to cherrypick those conclusions most suitable to it's own premises.

Narrows the world ever so slightly

This book is fine. The reading of it is fine. Together making for a .. sorta fine experience. The voice actor is good, but for this setting of “amazing, strange stories .. proceeded by skeptical tutting” it’s too neutral. Too stable & strict. I don’t remember a single performative or charming read of a line, nor hardly any emotion, really.

That mixes with the content of this book to absolutely do what it’s final moments remind us never to do, “never make the world smaller, only bigger.”

It’s sad that the “few genuinely lingering mysteries — the wheat among the countless chaff of nonsense encounters” according to the author are only discussed for the last 1% of the book. The other 99% is “describe, pique interest, reduce down to metaphor or psychological drive, etc.”

Bummer.

for the skeptical paranormal fan

Another great book from this author, a comparative cultural and psychological look at the unexplained, entertaining and enjoyable.

An Exploration of the Phenomenon of being Human

I really enjoyed this book. Dickey shares some amazing stories and then does a deep-dive into each one exploring the social issues at the time, the possible explanations, the evidence for and against, but really focusing on humanity. The book gives us a glimpse of why we need myths. I am a believer in the strange and unexplainable and I didn’t feel like Dickey was tearing apart these stories. He was respectful and inquisitive. It’s a fun read. :)