The Silent Witness: The Unsolved Murder of Mary Rogers

Shadows of the Past, Book 2

De: Eliza Hawthorne

Narrado por: Bruce Cannon

How did the death of a young woman captivate 19th-century New York and inspire one of Edgar Allan Poe’s most famous works?

Mary Rogers, a celebrated beauty and enigmatic figure in Manhattan, disappeared on a summer day in 1841. Days later, her lifeless body was discovered in the Hudson River, sparking a media frenzy and a public desperate for answers. What followed was a scandal that exposed the darkest corners of society—murder, mystery, and sensational speculation.

The Silent Witness delves deep into the unsolved murder of Mary Rogers, unraveling the secrets of her life, the failures of the justice system, and the way her case became a symbol of sensationalist media in America. Explore the societal pressures, public fascination, and cultural climate that transformed her tragedy into one of the most infamous crimes of the 19th century.

• Uncover a timeless mystery: Follow the gripping investigation into Mary’s untimely death and the theories that continue to fuel speculation today.
• See history come alive: Immerse yourself in the vibrant yet volatile streets of 1840s New York, where crime and scandal ruled the headlines.
• Perfect for book clubs: Includes thought-provoking discussion questions that encourage debate and deeper analysis of this chilling case.

Why this book stands out:

As the second installment in the acclaimed Shadows of the Past series, The Silent Witness combines meticulous research with a captivating narrative style. Listeners will gain new insights into Mary’s life, the public’s obsession with her death, and how her story influenced the literary world, including Poe’s classic The Mystery of Marie Rogêt.

If you love true crime, unsolved mysteries, or historical investigations, this book is a must

©2024 Cordova Consulting (P)2025 Cordova Consulting

A Fascinating Look at a Chilling Mystery

I had heard about this case before, but this book gave me a whole new perspective. The details were so well presented that I felt like I was piecing the mystery together alongside the investigators. I appreciated how it explored different theories without pushing just one answer, leaving room for my own thoughts on what really happened. It was both eerie and intriguing, and I found myself researching more after I finished. If you enjoy true crime that dives deep into history’s lingering questions, this is worth a read.

If you love a good Mystery?

Mary Rogers was more than just a tragic headline—she was a young woman whose mysterious death shook 19th-century New York. This book pulls you right into the heart of her story, from her disappearance to the shocking discovery of her body in the Hudson River. The media turned her case into a spectacle, justice was never served, and even Edgar Allan Poe used it as inspiration for The Mystery of Marie Rogêt. The deeper you go, the more unsettling it becomes. A haunting look at crime, media, and a case that still lingers in history.

Mystery, Murder and Drama

This audiobook pulls you right into 1841 New York and the chilling mystery of Mary Rogers’ murder. It’s packed with historical details, day-by-day investigation insights, and even Edgar Allan Poe’s eerie connection to the case. I loved how it balanced facts with a suspenseful story—every twist kept me hooked. If you’re into true crime, old-school mysteries, then this is a great book to listen to.

So good and so haunting!!!!

I absolutely loved The Silent Witness: The Unsolved Murder of Mary Rogers! Eliza Hawthorne does an incredible job weaving together historical facts and gripping storytelling, making this audiobook impossible to pause. The narration pulled me in, bringing the eerie mystery to life in such a vivid way. If you enjoy true crime with a historical twist, this is a must-listen!

Read this if you love historical true crime

This audiobook yanks you right into 1840s New York, where the disappearance of Mary Rogers became a media sensation. A mix of mystery, scandal, and public obsession, it is fascinatingly distasteful. What particularly drew me in was how the case showed flaws in justice and how sensationalist journalism would shape up. The connections with Edgar Allan Poe add another layer. Lively storytelling and good research make this an engrossing listen for anyone interested in crime, history, and the power of public perception.

INTRIGUING TRUE CRIME WITH GREAT DETAIL

This one pulled me in right away! The mix of historical mystery and true crime made for a fascinating listen. The storytelling is detailed without feeling overwhelming, and I liked how it explored different theories about what really happened. It’s a slower-paced but gripping deep dive into an unsolved case, perfect for history and crime fans. The narration kept me engaged, and I found myself thinking about the case long after I finished. Definitely worth a listen if you love real-life mysteries!

Chilling and Captivating

This book dives into a haunting historical mystery that kept me hooked from the start. The detailed storytelling brought the era to life, while the twists and theories surrounding Mary’s case left me fascinated and constantly guessing. The balance of fact and speculation is handled beautifully, making it a compelling read for true crime and history enthusiasts alike. It’s the kind of book that lingers in your mind long after you’ve finished. Highly recommend for fans of unsolved mysteries!

A Lifeline for Caregivers

As someone new to caregiving, I felt lost navigating medical jargon and emotional struggles. The practical advice helped me build a strong support system and better communicate with healthcare providers. I appreciated the compassion woven into the guidance—it reminded me I’m not alone. It’s a must-listen for anyone caring for a loved one with dementia.

A fascinating dive into a forgotten mystery

This audiobook masterfully unpacks the unsolved murder of Mary Rogers, shedding light on both the investigation and the media frenzy that followed. The level of historical detail is impressive, making 1840s New York feel alive—gritty, chaotic, and full of intrigue. What stood out most was how this case shaped public perception of crime and even influenced literature. A compelling listen for anyone who enjoys historical mysteries with real-world impact.

Early 1900s Society

The history written in this novel is narrated very well. The narrator uses an engaging tone that it make feel as if he is telling you specifically the story. The descriptive language is detailed. When you listen to the story, you realize that all social status have it though. It was interesting to realize how the lack to technology, and media an social class played a big role in the inability to solve the mystery of Mary Rogers' death.