The Fifth Act

America’s End in Afghanistan

De: Elliot Ackerman

Narrado por: Elliot Ackerman

A Times Political Book of the Year 2022

A powerful and revelatory eyewitness account of the American collapse in Afghanistan, its desperate endgame, and the war’s echoing legacy.

Elliot Ackerman left the American military ten years ago, but his time in Afghanistan and Iraq with the Marines and, later, as a CIA paramilitary officer marked him indelibly. When the Taliban began to close in on Kabul in August of 2021 and the Afghan regime began its death spiral, he found himself pulled back into the conflict. The official evacuation process was a bureaucratic failure that led to a humanitarian catastrophe. Ackerman was drawn into an impromptu effort to arrange flights and negotiate with both Taliban and American forces to secure the safe evacuation of hundreds. These were desperate measures taken during a desperate end to America’s longest war, but the success they achieved afforded a degree of redemption: and, for Ackerman, a chance to reconcile his past with his present.

The Fifth Act is an astonishing human document that brings the weight of twenty years of war to bear on a single week at its bitter end. Using the dramatic rescue efforts in Kabul as his lattice, Ackerman weaves in a personal history of the war's long progress, beginning with the initial invasion in the months after 9/11.

It is a play in five acts with a tragic denouement. Any listener who wants to understand what went wrong with the war’s trajectory will find a trenchant accounting here. And yet The Fifth Act is not an exercise in finger-pointing: it brings listeners into close contact with a remarkable group of characters, who fought the war with courage and dedication, in good faith and at great personal cost. Understanding combatants’ experiences and sacrifices demands reservoirs of wisdom and the gifts of an extraordinary storyteller. In Elliot Ackerman, this story has found that author. The Fifth Act is a first draft of history that feels like a timeless classic.

©2022 Elliot Ackerman (P)2022 HarperCollins Publishers Limited

Reseñas de la Crítica

"The American betrayal of Afghanistan took twenty years. Elliot Ackerman, a participant and witness, tells the story with unsparing honesty in this intensely personal chronicle." (George Packer, author of The Unwinding and Last Best Hope)

"His understanding of war is so profound that one feels like secrets have been revealed—truths—information that one day may be necessary for our survival." (Sebastian Junger, author of War and Tribe)

"Making sense of chaos is never easy, but this powerful book does much to explain why America’s debacle in Afghanistan ended the way it did … Courage and folly, dedication and tragedy: Ackerman deftly captures all dimensions of a protracted foreign policy failure … A must-read account of the end of America’s longest war." (Kirkus Reviews)

A lot to think about

I expected to find a personal recollection of the withdrawal from Afghanistan. In some instances, my expectations were exceeded: the author's reflections on modern wars that can't be won and his comparison of Vietnam war with Afghanistan leave a lot to think about. However, the factual, personal part concerning Afghanistan war contains confusing jumps in time, from 2001 to 2021. Recollections are the most memorable events of the author's 20 years in military: first as an infantryman, then in Marine corps, then in CIA. The withdrawal itself happened after the author left active duty, but through hia connections, he took part in exfiltration of American allies from Kabul.