The Drive on Moscow, 1941

Operation Taifun and Germany’s First Great Crisis of World War II

De: Niklas Zetterling, Anders Frankson

Narrado por: Dave Courvoisier

At the end of September 1941, more than a million German soldiers lined up along the frontline just 180 miles west of Moscow. They were well trained, confident, and had good reasons to hope that the war in the East would be over with one last offensive. Facing them was an equally large Soviet force, but whose soldiers were neither as well trained nor as confident. When the Germans struck, disaster soon befell the Soviet defenders. German panzer spearheads cut through enemy defenses and thrust deeply to encircle most of the Soviet soldiers on the approaches to Moscow. Within a few weeks, most of them marched into captivity, where a grim fate awaited them.

Despite the overwhelming initial German success, however, the Soviet capital did not fall. German combat units as well as supply transport were bogged down in mud caused by autumn rains. General Zhukov was called back to Moscow and given the desperate task to recreate defense lines west of Moscow. The mud allowed him time to accomplish this, and when the Germans again began to attack in November, they met stiffer resistance. Even so, they came perilously close to the capital, and if the vicissitudes of weather had cooperated, would have seized it. Though German units were also fighting desperately by now, the Soviet build-up soon exceeded their own.

The Drive on Moscow: Operation Taifun, 1941 is based on numerous archival records, personal diaries, letters, and other sources. It recreates the battle from the perspective of the soldiers as well as the generals. The battle, not fought in isolation, had a crucial role in the overall German strategy in the East, and its outcome reveals why the failure of the German assault on Moscow may well have been true turning point of World War II.

Niklas Zetterling is a researcher at the Swedish Defense College. Along with Anders Frankson he has previously written Kursk 1943: A Statistical Analysis and The Korsun Pocket: The Encirclement and Breakout of a German Army in the East, 1944. Both authors currently live in Sweden.

©2012 Niklas Zetterling and Anders Frankson (P)2013 Audible, Inc.

Add the maps, lose the accents

Would you consider the audio edition of The Drive on Moscow, 1941 to be better than the print version?

No due to absence of maps available for the audio edition.

What did you like best about this story?

Detailed research

What do you think the narrator could have done better?

I really wish narrators of historical nonfiction would not adopt cheesy accents when reading quoted first person accounts. Just read. Save the acting for fiction titles,

Good review of an important battle

Like most military books I listen too, not having maps available to understand the shape of the battle was challenging. However, the reader did a fine job of pronouncing Russian and German names which helped keep the story clear.

Choppy but excellent overall

What made the experience of listening to The Drive on Moscow, 1941 the most enjoyable?

The book in its entirety. Parts were weak. Author brought it all together finally.

What did you like best about this story?

The author's perspective and reasoning about the role of The Drive on Moscow in WWII.

Would you be willing to try another one of Dave Courvoisier’s performances?

Yes will try, but not looking forward to it. He sounds like an ad reader rather than a book reader.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

When the author stopped talking about deep details and spoke about the decision to be at Moscow's door and why Germany lost. His analysis about the role of the weather is brilliant.

Competent Narrative, Unconvincing/Lacking Thesis

Overall, this text makes interesting points, especially related to the German priorities of war production. However, the thesis is not well formed and of itself not born out by the narrative. The text leaves the impression that weather and conditions and operational choices halted the Germans more than resistance (which is not difficult to agree with). In fact the Germans, other than encircling the city, scored a major operational success , despite being forced to retreat. Ultimately, while a chronological narrative is examined as to why the advance was halted, little explanation is conducted related to why it was essential to win at that exact moment and why the war could not be won as a result of that moment. It would have been better to argue that merely going to war with Russia was the moment the war was lost, but this would defeat the purpose of the book. More disappointingly, once the advance comes to a halt, so does the book. To make matters worse, the accents adopted by the Narrator only detract from the otherwise bland reading. In contrast, I would recommend reading/listening to David Stahel's "Retreat from Moscow".

Please Remove the Silly Accents

What made the experience of listening to The Drive on Moscow, 1941 the most enjoyable?

The story is told in an interesting manner, without sacrificing detail.

Who would you have cast as narrator instead of Dave Courvoisier?

If he just would drop the ridiculous accents on Germans and Russians, there would be no reason to change narrator.

You need a map

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

It was reasonably well-spent

What do you think your next listen will be?

Bill The Bastard

What do you think the narrator could have done better?

The way in which the distances were always converted to imperial measurements for those who do not think metric was annoying. I don't think that anyone who took the time to listen to the book would have needed the distance conversion.

Could you see The Drive on Moscow, 1941 being made into a movie or a TV series? Who should the stars be?

Perhaps. Don't know

Any additional comments?

You really need a map to appreciate the locations and where the battles occurred.

Decent

It needs maps downloadable as pdfs. Also the narrator should stop doing accents. But overall enjoyable and informative.