Road to Disaster

A New History of America’s Descent into Vietnam

De: Brian VanDeMark

Narrado por: Ron Butler

"The most thoughtful and judicious one-volume history of the war and the American political leaders who presided over the difficult and painful decisions that shaped this history. The book will stand for the foreseeable future as the best study of the tragic mistakes that led to so much suffering." (Robert Dallek)

Many books have been written on the tragic decisions regarding Vietnam made by the young stars of the Kennedy and Johnson administrations. Yet despite millions of words of analysis and reflection, no historian has been able to explain why such decent, brilliant, and previously successful men stumbled so badly.

That changes with Road to Disaster. Historian Brian VanDeMark draws upon decades of archival research, his own interviews with many of those involved, and a wealth of previously unheard recordings by Robert McNamara and Clark Clifford, who served as Defense Secretaries for Kennedy and Johnson. Yet beyond that, Road to Disaster is also the first history of the war to look at the cataclysmic decisions of those in the Kennedy and Johnson administrations through the prism of recent research in cognitive science, psychology, and organizational theory to explain why the "Best and the Brightest" became trapped in situations that suffocated creative thinking and willingness to dissent, why they found change so hard, and why they were so blind to their own errors.

An epic history of America’s march to quagmire, Road to Disaster is a landmark in scholarship and a book of immense importance.

©2018 Brian VanDeMark (P)2018 HarperCollins Publishers

Clarity of the readers voice

Excellent reading of a complex subject and a very important t part of our history

A phenomenal read for amateur historians and behavioral economists.

The book is able to narrate the events leading up to the Vietnam war with amazing primary source evidences. It is further able to explain the context and reasoning of the protagonists using psychological research and behavioral economics. This is palatable for all readers and definitely something informative.

Interesting interpretation of Vietnam decisions

This new book on the Vietnam War takes a different approach to the usual book on the subject. It focuses on the personalities and decision-making of the Washington DC based politicians (Eisenhower, Kennedy & Johnson administrations), cabinet members & other advisors, and the military leadership. Van DeMark also gives a window to flaws in the psychology, personal and organizational, that contributed powerfully to decisionmaking patterns. He usefully explicates the flaws in decisionmaking in the context of Vietnam, but employs examples from the psychology research literature to illustrate these points. The book is not the be all & end all on Vietnam, no book can be. But because of its focus on decisionmaking it makes a great new contribution to understanding what happened & why it happened. The book has good narrative drive and a very effective narrator.

An exceptional book exploring flawed decision making

This book brings a behavior economics lens to the decisions driving the continued involvement and escalation of the US in the Vietnam conflict. I’ve read a number of books on Vietnam, but this was one of the best. I highly recommend it.

A+

I have read a vast amount of books on Vietnam combat and general history, but Road To Disaster took me on an incredible ride through the political view of our descent into the war. I learned much about the top echelons on government and their decision making regarding the initial involvement in SE Asia and its escalation. Narration for this book was perfect. Mr. Butler did a fantastic job. I could listen to him for hours on end (and often did).

Vietnam Veteran

As a Vietnam veteran I lived in a world believing myths and opinions of Vietnam that in some part were untrue and other just not believable. This book opened my eyes to what really happened and why. It is very well done and documented. The narrator reading is superior. Thanks to the author and all the people involved in writing this account of the Vietnam tragedy. I lived this entire period as a member of the US Army, from the Bay of Pigs to the Vietnam War, and retired in January 1985 as a Command Sergeant Major.

On academics and word choice

Early on I read this sentence: “Mental mistakes are inherent in human nature.”

In grad school I’d have written something similar. Now I’d write, “We all make mistakes.”

This is a good study and worthwhile. But please spare me the academic prose.

When academics learn English and stop trying to impress those of their ilk then they’ll sell some books.

A uniquely well informed history

A uniquely well informed comparative history of national decision-making covering the three crises in the title. Outstanding. This would make great assigned reading for an International Relations course as an example of cognitive decision-making theory applied to case studies.

Great analysis

Road to Disaster is an engaging, well articulated critique of many factors that led to political and military disaster in Vietnam, including a similar and prophetic summary of failures related to the Bay of Pigs fiasco. This is NOT a regurgitation of battles, but rather a look at high level miscalculations, misunderstandings, the impact of having unreliable ally and an unpredictable foe, and often poorly considered decision making by well-intentioned but imperfect, politically influenced, and often ill-informed political and military officials. Arguably, many of the same errors were repeated in both Iraq and Afghanistan.

fantastic overview and concly

I really like the perspective of this book. refreshing. I learned a lot about Robert McNamara.