Oneida

From Free Love Utopia to the Well-Set Table

De: Ellen Wayland-Smith

Narrado por: Khristine Hvam

In the early 19th century, many Americans were looking for an alternative to the Puritanism that had been the foundation of the new country. Amid the fervor of the religious revival known as the Second Great Awakening, John Humphrey Noyes, a spirited but socially awkward young man, attracted a group of devoted followers with his fiery sermons about creating Jesus' millennial kingdom here on Earth.

Noyes established a revolutionary community in rural New York centered around achieving a life free of sin through God's grace while also espousing equality of the sexes and "complex marriage", a system of free love where sexual relations with multiple partners was encouraged. When the community disbanded in 1880, a new generation of Oneidans sought to exorcise the ghost of their fathers' disreputable sexual theories. Converted into a joint-stock company, Oneida Community, Limited, would go on to become one of the nation's leading manufacturers of silverware.

Told by a descendant of one of the community's original families, Oneida is a captivating story that straddles two centuries to reveal how a radical, free-love sect transformed into a purveyor of the white-picket-fence American dream.

©2016 Ellen Wayland-Smith (P)2016 Tantor

Reseñas de la Crítica

"This book is a fascinating look into the strange history of Oneida silverware and how its origins reflect an exhilarating period of American history." ( Publishers Weekly)

Narration was annoying

Seemed like the writer had a per word contract. Although at times, very vivid, there were far too many words used to get a point across.

A fascinating story but, because of the performance, I longed for the story to end, but could only stand to have it read about an hour at a time. The male/female voice inflection was overdone. A great walk through history during the Industrial Age of the US.

Interesting Read

Stars: 4
Format: Audiobook
Series: Stand Alone
Steam Level: None

Holy smokes this was a ride. I figured from the title it would be interesting but I didn’t think it would be THAT interesting. The beginning was pretty slow and I nearly put it down, and I probably would have if I wasn’t listening to it. Just get to Putnam, it picks up from there and you’ll see how Noyes’ early life and surrounding history played a part in shaping the community.

Quick Thoughts:
- This story shows just how society swings from conservative about sex to liberal about sex to conservative about sex to liberal about sex, constantly
- This book was bananas
- It was one heck of a turn from what it started out as to selling tableware
- The narrator, Khristin Hvam, for this audiobook was very good and I’ll definitely listen to another by her
- Did I mention it’s bananas?
- There were parts that creeped me out but I applaud the author for including them when it would have been easy not to
- I ended up getting on my phone a lot to look up images/photos of the Oneida Community, so keep yours close
- Bananas… just… bananas

Overall, I strongly recommend getting through the slow beginning (and don’t skip it!) to the real bananas parts later. It’s worth it.

Fascinating social history

What did you love best about Oneida?

This is a fascinating social history of the United States in the 19th and 20th centuries. The stsory weaves together religious innovations, utopian experiments, labor and industry history. Not a dull moment. And the reader gives an outstanding performance.

What was one of the most memorable moments of Oneida?

The description of the marital arrangements with its attempt to wipe out all exclusive personal attachments. This is the most eccentric but engrossing part of the story.

Which scene was your favorite?

No particualrly favorite scene, but I chose this book because I needed to use some credits. I was surprised by how good it is.

Any additional comments?

This recording is what a recorded book should be, a well written, informative, entertaining story perfectly read by the narrator.

The Persistence of the American fantasy

Over the course of several books covering different aspects of this period I am perpetually struck by how America is still transfixed by a fantasy of self-identity that was rooted in the early 1800s and blossomed in the Gilded Age.

This work is a must read, brilliantly done, and with a n insight and empathy that goes beyond the core subject material, a rare find in a work of history.

Time Well Spent

Especially in light of the "Burning", this book serves an important purpose in its encyclopedic account of the history of Oneida, which is at times incompatible with crisp story telling. By the end, the reader will feel rewarded for granting the author this indulgence. Most 21st century Americans lack sufficient appreciation for the explosion of free thinking and radical experimentation occasioned by our liberation from the English monarchy. This book will cure that deficiency.

Terrible Narrator

Too breathy, over the top. Thought it would get better, but no. Reading the book would probably be better.